Mind-boggling sexual assault trial is fraught with gender issues: DiManno


Mind-boggling sexual assault trial is fraught with gender issues: DiManno
  1. Mind-boggling sexual assault trial is fraught with gender issues: DiManno
    thestar.com
    The accused self-identifies as female, but is formally called Patrick Pearsall in court documents. Pearsall faces two counts of sexual assault. By a man against two…
    Crime
The accused self-identifies as female and prefers to be known as “Tara,” the name of his former wife, but is formally called Patrick Pearsall in court documents. By Rosie DiMannoColumnist Fri., May 19, 2017

My first thought, upon entering the courtroom: Where’s the accused?

Not in the dock, not at the defense table.

And then it dawned on me. Oh, that’s him. Or her. Sitting alongside his legal counsel. Or her legal counsel.

I’m not playing disingenuous gender games here. Transgendered sexual identity is no longer a matter for tittering, if ever it was. It’s just that the defendant in court Friday looked not at all like the individual in the police handout photo, which was my reference point. Meaning, he — presenting as female — appears far older than 52 years of age, all wrinkly, with face collapsing inwards, nose curving down towards his protruding lower bite, and a thin grey bob of hair.

I would never have identified him in a police lineup.

Article Continued Below

To be clear: The accused self-identifies as female and prefers to be known as “Tara,” the name of his former wife, but is formally called Patrick Pearsall in court documents.

As Crown attorney Jonathan Smith noted in his opening address to the jury earlier in the week, the alleged victims knew him as “Pat” or Patrick, and thus will refer to him by those names. “It is by no means an issue of disrespect for the defendant’s wishes to be referred to as Tara.”

That’s the no-offense-intended preamble.

The offenses at issue are two counts of sexual assault.

By a man against two women.

At least at the time of the alleged assaults outwardly presenting as a man married to a woman.

It gets confusing because — as per her preference — the appropriate pronouns for purpose of this account are a muddle.

Also presenting, as one alleged victim testified, as a paramedic to one accuser and as a doctor to another.

It can be firmly stated that he was never either.

But those were the professional roles he allegedly assumed to convince the women they should allow him to perform vaginal examinations on them.

Those were the alleged sexual assaults, to which Pearsall has pleaded not guilty.

One accuser, first to take the stand, was a 21-year-old homeless woman when she met Pearsall and his wife Tara Jean Tracey in the spring of 2008.

At the time, she’d been drifting among homeless shelters, coping with drug use and was pregnant by an abusive boyfriend, although she didn’t know her condition when she accepted an offer from the couple to move into their Toronto Community Housing apartment, paying modest rent for a room.

In fact, she scarcely knew the couple, having met Tracey on social media.

Within a few weeks of moving into the unit, the witness — a publication ban prevents identifying either of the alleged victims — began to experience vaginal bleeding.

At this point in her life, the young woman had never had a miscarriage (but had undergone seven abortions) and didn’t understand what was happening.

It was Tracey, she testified, who urged that she allow Pearsall, the “paramedic” to take a look down under.

The woman agreed and pulled down her pants, lowering herself onto a futon. The “examination” lasted 10 minutes, with Pearsall allegedly penetrating her digitally.

“I was young. I was naïve, and his so-called wife was encouraging it,” Witness A said under cross-examination yesterday. “He gave me two choices: go to the hospital or he could, quote, f__k the baby back inside me.”

That’s right.

Either get herself to emergency, where the ailing fetus would be extracted, or have sex with him because that would halt the miscarriage.

But Witness A wasn’t quite that naïve.

“I know you can’t f__k a baby back into a person.”

She drew up her trousers and got out of there lickety-split, never went to police.

Two years later, she told the court, she heard from Tracey that Pearsall had been convicted of sexually assaulting a 16-year-old pregnant girl in Halifax after befriending that homeless teenager and her boyfriend.

In that case, Pearsall had claimed to be a doctor, warning the girl she might be having a miscarriage, a problem that could be fixed by having sex with him.

At trial, Smith said in his opening address, Pearsall admitted these facts and others before being convicted of sexual assault obtained by fraud.

On the stand yesterday, Witness A admitted she’d seen a story online about Pearsall being convicted as a sexual offender. But she denied seeking out any further reported details, such as Pearsall telling the Halifax teenager he could “fix her” by injecting fluid into her vagina.

The story now jumps forward to 2015 to another teen, age 17, who’d never met or heard of the Witness A.

This girl was in the care of the Children’s Aid society, living in a group home, her boyfriend in a foster home. She, too, was all screwed up — drugs, self-harming by cutting herself repeatedly on the legs and torso, suicidal thoughts.

That spring, Witness B discovered she was pregnant. Fearful of being removed from the group home and having her baby taken away, she fled.

This young woman has yet to testify. But the court was told in the Crown’s opening address that, upon running …

The accused self-identifies as female and prefers to be known as “Tara,” the name of his former wife, but is formally called Patrick Pearsall in court documents.
  1. Toronto police board to consider suspending school officer program

    Thestar.com - Crime
    05.24 / 01:08 www.thestar.com
    After heated debate on the negative effect of uniformed officers in schools, the Toronto Police Services Board came to the verge of suspending the School Resource Officer program, pending a meeting with school and community…
  2. Four Dead in Canoe Accident in Thompson

    Netnewsledger.com - Crime
    05.23 / 22:21 www.netnewsledger.com
    THOMPSON – On Monday, May 22, 2017, Thompson RCMP and Thompson Fire and Emergency Services were advised of a group of four overdue canoers who were out paddling on the Burntwood River, North of the City of Thompson, Manitoba. Police officers and fire fighters launched two rescue boats and initiated a water search of the Burntwood […] The Article Four Dead in Canoe Accident in Thompson by NetNewsLedger first appeared on NetNewsLedger - Thunder Bay News - News at the Speed of the …
  3. Ontario Coroner Confirms Josiah Begg was Body in McIntyre River

    Netnewsledger.com - Crime
    05.23 / 22:21 www.netnewsledger.com
    THUNDER BAY – The worst fears of the family and friends of Josiah Begg were confirmed today. The Thunder Bay Police Service Criminal Investigation Branch were contacted this afternoon by the Chief Coroner of Ontario who confirmed that the male found deceased in the McIntyre River was fourteen-year-old Josiah Begg. Josiah’s family had been previously […] The Article Ontario Coroner Confirms Josiah Begg was Body in McIntyre River by NetNewsLedger first appeared on…
  4. Officer facing three misconduct charges stemming from High Park suicide

    Thestar.com - Crime
    05.23 / 19:00 www.thestar.com
    The Toronto police officer charged with breach of trust in connection with a High Park suicide last year is alleged to have refused to help a citizen attempting to enlist his assistance, according to Toronto police tribunal…
  5. Man sought after Oshawa home invasion found safe

    Thestar.com - Crime
    05.23 / 17:52 www.thestar.com
    Francis O'Connor was located unharmed after May 18 incident involving three armed…
  6. Friends remember slain Brampton woman as ‘caring, selfless’

    Thestar.com - Crime
    05.22 / 23:03 www.thestar.com
    Beata Paciorek, found dead near Sault Ste. Marie Sunday, was described by friends as a ‘sweetheart’ who got involved with the wrong cro…