Judge slams law, delays sentencing

Judge slams law, delays sentencing
  1. Judge slams law, delays sentencing
    In a case that has raised questions about the effect of mandatory minimum sentences, a Manitoba judge has taken pity on a woman he convicted by agreeing to give her…

In a case that has raised questions about the effect of mandatory minimum sentences, a Manitoba judge has taken pity on a woman he convicted by agreeing to give her more freedom before he sends her to prison.

In a likely unprecedented move, Justice Sheldon Lanchbery reserved his decision and delayed the sentencing of 37-year-old Sandra Dignard by about two months. That will allow the mother of four time to make child-care arrangements before she is placed in custody. The judge said he has no choice but to sentence Dignard to two years in prison for drug trafficking, despite his belief she should not be locked up.

KEN GIGLIOTTI / WINNIPEG FREE PRESS FILES</p><p>Justice Sheldon Lanchbery, in a 2013 file photo, reserved his decision and delayed the sentencing of 37-year-old woman to allow the mother of four time to make child-care arrangements before she is placed in custody.</p>

Justice Sheldon Lanchbery, in a 2013 file photo, reserved his decision and delayed the sentencing of 37-year-old woman to allow the mother of four time to make child-care arrangements before she is placed in custody.

"" src="http://media.winnipegfreepress.com/images/400*483/NEP2511887.jpg" class="imglf" width="399" />

"I’m not without heart. I’m not a fan of mandatory minimums because I believe that justices or judges have the ability to sort the wheat from the chaff," the judge said as he prepared to impose the two-year mandatory minimum sentence in Court of Queen’s Bench this week.

"There’s no doubt in my mind that this is one (case) that no right-thinking person could imagine that what I’m going to have to do today is fit and proper, and I don’t see any way I can work around them."

Lanchbery had convicted Dignard of smuggling painkillers into Stony Mountain Institution in 2012 at the instruction of her boyfriend, who was then a Hells Angels prospect.

She hid 100 morphine pills — worth about $10,000 — on her body when she went for a conjugal visit. Dignard had earlier taken drugs into the prison at the behest of her boyfriend, who had active gang ties and a criminal record rife with drugs and weapons offences, court heard.

She was charged with drug trafficking within an institution in 2014 and has been free on bail since then. While the judge decided the case didn’t meet the legal test for committing a crime under duress, he agreed Dignard had been manipulated and victimized.

"He was using the mother of his children, but that doesn’t get you to the point of being forgiven for the offence," Lanchbery told Dignard.

Still, the childhood abuse she suffered that bled into her adult relationships made Dignard, in many ways, a victim, the judge acknowledged.

The former boyfriend who manipulated her testified about his involvement at her trial, but he was never charged in relation to the incident.

The case struck an emotional chord with each of the lawyers involved, with Crown and defence agreeing Dignard would have been a good candidate to serve her sentence under house arrest and avoid jail time, if the law allowed.

Her crime carries a mandatory minimum two years in prison, even though she had no criminal record before being charged and has not violated any of her court orders since the charge was laid. During the past few years, Dignard has sobered up, cut ties with her boyfriend and works hard to be a good mother to her kids, two of whom have special needs, court heard.

Dignard pleaded with the judge not to jail her, saying she knew she did wrong and "will take any other punishment you give me."

"I’m sorry for what I did, letting a man manipulate me and put me and my children in this horrible situation," she said during a brief but tearful speech in court.

"My kids are who I live for, and I changed my life for them, took alcohol and drugs out of my life. I’m begging you not to take me away from my kids and put them in the system."

Lanchbery reserved his sentencing decision until July 26 at her request, noting Dignard had "touched the hearts of three people in this room who usually don’t find themselves in this situation."

But he made clear he will impose the two-year sentence as mandated by federal legislation.

"Yes, I have discretion, but there’s a reason why those mandatory minimums are in place. I don’t agree with them, but I am required to follow the law as well," he said.

Defence lawyer Steven Keesic, who saw Dignard’s austere living situation first-hand, said it was one of the most difficult cases he’s worked on.

He said he had initially planned to launch a Charter of Rights and Freedoms challenge, arguing the two-year mandatory minimum sentence amounted to cruel and unusual punishment in this case but didn’t have enough resources to do so.

"Justice was not served in this case," he told the Free Press.

"Sometimes lawyers have cases where your clients are easy to fight for, but when you get an outcome like this, where your options are limited and resources for poor people are not available, you really almost wish you never were counsel because at the end of the day, you did everything in your power to fight hard for the client and go to trial, just to get two years."

Several recent mandatory minimum sentences, including for drug crimes, were introduced under Stephen Harper’s Conservative government about five years ago as part of a tough-on-crime, "truth in sentencing" agenda. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has announced the current…

  1. MLA's filibuster gets filibustered

    Winnipegfreepress.com - Menitoba
    PROGRESSIVE Conservative MLA Steven Fletcher continued to stall passage of a government bill Tuesday evening that would create a new Crown corporation responsible for energy efficiency programs in Manitoba. Using points…
  2. Manitoba seniors' safety program shuttering after $150K in funding cut

    Cbc.ca - Manitoba
    05.24 / 02:52 www.cbc.ca
    For 14 years the SafetyAid program has been going into homes to make Manitoba seniors safer. The last thing they expected was for their funding to be…
  3. Efficiency Manitoba doesn't seem efficient to PC MLA

    Cbc.ca - Manitoba
    05.24 / 02:29 www.cbc.ca
    It would be Manitoba's newest crown corporation, but Tory MLA Steven Fletcher doesn't see anything efficient about Efficiency…
  4. Tying minimum wage to inflation draws fire from unions, business

    Winnipegfreepress.com - Menitoba
    T he Pallister government took it from all sides at a public hearing Tuesday night into its proposed legislation on the minimum wage. The Tories want to take the $11-an-hour minimum wage…
  5. Banner year for photo radar cash cow

    Winnipegsun.com - Winnipeg
    05.24 / 00:27 www.winnipegsun.com
    The photo enforcement camera at the corner of Main Street and Logan Avenue was the top money maker for the city of Winnipeg last year and remains its biggest cash cow of all time since police began installing the cameras in…
  6. OPP identify 8-year-old Winnipeg boy who drowned in Rushing River Provincial Park

    Globalnews.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 23:03 globalnews.ca
    Drowning was the cause of death of an 8-year-old Winnipeg boy who died over the weekend, according to an Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) news…
  7. 'My hero:' Two fathers and their young sons die in Manitoba canoeing accident

    Winnipeg.ctvnews.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 22:52 winnipeg.ctvnews.ca
    A young man says he's devastated after his father and his dad's best friend died in a canoeing accident in northern Manitoba along with two of their…
  8. 'Keep your kids close': Winnipeg parents give tearful plea after son drowns

    Cbc.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 22:40 www.cbc.ca
    The parents of a nine-year-old boy who drowned over the weekend have a desperate plea to other parents as they prepare to say goodbye to their beloved son one last…
  9. Enhanced security planned at MTS Centre following Manchester Arena attack

    Winnipeg.ctvnews.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 22:30 winnipeg.ctvnews.ca
    You may notice enhanced security at this Friday’s sold-out Red Hot Chili Peppers show at MTS Centre but the added public safety measures won't stop t…
  10. Development of Winnipeg’s Kapyong Barracks inching ahead

    Globalnews.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 22:17 globalnews.ca
    Seven First Nations Chiefs, part of Treaty One, met with federal government officials Tuesday at 17 Wing to discuss their plans for the 158 acres of land along Kenaston…
  11. 'This changes everything': True North beefs up MTS Centre security after Manchester attack

    Cbc.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 22:16 www.cbc.ca
    Winnipeg Police with True North Sports and Entertainment announced Monday they will be using a bomb-sniffing dog as part of enhanced security measures at the downtown arena after the deadly explosion at the Ariana Grande concert in Manchester, U.K. Sunday…
  12. Kinew lines up support, commits to gender balance goal

    Winnipegfreepress.com - Menitoba
    NDP leadership candidate Wab Kinew received several high-profile endorsements Tuesday while announcing a commitment to achieve gender balance in future NDP caucuses. At a news conference on the west lawn of…
  13. Police seek vehicle in fatal hit and run

    Winnipegsun.com - Winnipeg
    05.23 / 22:12 www.winnipegsun.com
    Winnipeg police is requesting the public’s assistance in finding the driver and vehicle they believed was involved in the fatal hit and run collision that occurred Sunday morning in the 300 block of Cumberland Avenue at Carleton S…
  14. 9-year-old boy slipped on rock, drowned in Rushing River Provincial Park: Father

    Winnipeg.ctvnews.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 21:41 winnipeg.ctvnews.ca
    The father of a 9-year old boy who died in Rushing River Provincial Park said his son Kyree Bruneau-Thomas slipped on a rock and drowned this…
  15. Winnipeg Blue Bombers GM ready for training camp to kick off

    Globalnews.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 21:29 globalnews.ca
    Of the four training camps Kyle Walters has been in charge, the Winnipeg Blue Bombers general manager finds this year's to be the most…
  16. Kinew gets more support for NDP leadership bid

    Winnipegsun.com - Manitoba
    05.23 / 21:01 www.winnipegsun.com
    Author, indigenous rights activist and rookie politician Wab Kinew has picked up more endorsements in his bid to become leader of the Manitoba New…
  17. Two dead in head-on collision

    Winnipegsun.com - Manitoba
    05.23 / 21:01 www.winnipegsun.com
    Two people are dead after a head-on collision in southern…
  18. Tragic end for four canoers near Thompson

    Winnipegsun.com - Manitoba
    05.23 / 21:01 www.winnipegsun.com
    Two youths, ages 6 and 14, along with two other men were killed Monday when the canoe they were in overturned in the Burntwood River north of Thompson, RCMP…
  19. Winnipeg police on the hunt for driver in fatal hit and run

    Cbc.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 20:43 www.cbc.ca
    Winnipeg police are asking for the public's help in finding the driver of a fatal hit and run crash that left a 30-year-old man dead in downtown Winnipeg Sunday…
  20. Manitoba woman breaks her back in bike crash in remote Indonesia

    Cbc.ca - Manitoba
    05.23 / 20:43 www.cbc.ca
    A Manitoba woman is in a hospital on the Indonesian island of Bali with serious injuries after a freak accident in a remote area of the country this past…