Trump’s Muslim ban is eerily similar to Israel’s refugee policies


Trump’s Muslim ban is eerily similar to Israel’s refugee policies
  1. Trump’s Muslim ban is eerily similar to Israel’s refugee policies
    972mag.com
    As President Trump seeks to maintain white Christian hegemony, the Jewish state can serve as a case study of nationalism run amuck — and what that means for the ‘others’ who live there. Israel’s founding premise that it would be a “Jewish and democratic” state has always meant that if the state wants to remain democratic [……
    Israel

As President Trump seeks to maintain white Christian hegemony, the Jewish state can serve as a case study of nationalism run amuck — and what that means for the ‘others’ who live there.

Hundreds fill New York City’s Washington Square Park to protest President Trump’s decision to ban Muslim refugees from entering the U.S., January 26, 2017. (Gili Getz)

Israel’s founding premise that it would be a “Jewish and democratic” state has always meant that if the state wants to remain democratic it must maintain a Jewish majority. Artificially maintaining a certain ethno-religious majority has led Israel to take some decidedly undemocratic measures against various minority populations.

Related stories
  • Trump is pushing American Jews away from Israel — and that's a good thing By Michael Sidmann | March 7, 2017
  • Anti-Semitism in the U.S. doesn’t make me want to move to Israel By Sarah Stern | March 1, 2017
  • PHOTOS: Americans, Israelis protest Trump refugee ban in J'lm and Tel Aviv By Natasha Roth | January 30, 2017
  • Netanyahu’s wall isn’t about immigration — it’s about race By Asaf Calderon | February 3, 2017

In the United States these days, President Donald Trump is also seeking to maintain a particular ethno-religious hegemony — that of white Christians. What does that mean for the future of the United States and its democratic institutions? Israel, where questions of national identity take on existential proportions, can provide important lessons. The Jewish state can serve as a case study of nationalism run amuck and what that means for the “others”—in this case, non-Jews—who live there.

My new book, “The Unchosen: The Lives of Israel’s New Others,” focuses on two groups of “others” in Israel: migrant workers from Southeast Asia and African asylum seekers. Significantly, a large number of the asylum seekers in Israel are from Sudan, one of the countries on Trump’s “travel ban” list, which has also been referred to as the “Muslim ban.” Who are these people that are targeted by both Trump and Israel? Why did they leave Sudan? What were they escaping? What are their hopes and dreams for the future?

Asylum seekers from Eritrea and Sudan protest the Israeli governments neglect to review asylum requests, and the states detention policies, at a demonstration held at Rabin Square, central Tel Aviv. March 29, 2014. (Tomer Neuberg/Flash90)

Asylum seekers from Eritrea and Sudan protest the Israeli government’s neglect to review asylum requests, and the state’s detention policies, at a demonstration held at Rabin Square, central Tel Aviv. March 29, 2014. (Tomer Neuberg/Flash90)

“The Unchosen” offers an intimate look at the lives of Sudanese asylum seekers. Almost all African asylum seekers in Israel are denied legal status — and while Israel claims that they’re actually illegal work migrants, the state can’t deport them because to do so would violate the international law against repatriating asylum seekers to a country where they could face persecution or death. So Israel keeps them in legal limbo, hoping that they will “self-deport” if you will.

To maintain its Jewish majority, Israel uses a variety of policies that, taken together, also constitute a Muslim ban. Palestinian refugees cannot return to the lands they lost during the 1948 war. For nearly 15 years, a law banning family unification means that if a Palestinian from the West Bank or Gaza marries a Palestinian who lives in Israel, they cannot come to Israel to reside with their spouse. The same is true of non-Jewish citizens of Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Lebanon who might marry a citizen of Israel – there is no legal avenue for them to actually live with their spouse in Israel.

Mya Guarnieris book, The Unchosen.

Mya Guarnieri’s new book, ‘The Unchosen.’

Another, more commonly cited parallel, is the separation barrier Israel built along its southern border with Egypt to stop Sudanese and Eritrean asylum seekers from entering the country. A key component of Donald Trump’s presidential campaign was his promise to build a wall along the the United States’ southern border with Mexico. While many observers liken Trump’s proposed wall to the one that stands between Israel and the occupied Palestinian territories, the barrier between Israel and Egypt is more analogous.

Why? First of all, the African asylum seekers who used to enter through Israel’s southern border have been falsely portrayed by both the Israeli government and Israeli media as “work migrants” or “work infiltrators” or just “infiltrators.” They’ve been depicted as people who rob Israelis of jobs, who rape, who sell drugs, who pose a threat to the very character of the country.

Sound familiar? It’s almost identical to the way Trump depicts Latino immigrants.

In…

Hundreds fill New York Citys Washington Square Park to protest President Trumps decision to ban Muslim refugees from entering the U.S., January 26, 2017. (Gili Getz)
  1. Liberman May Support Pardon for Elor Azaria

    Hamodia.com - Israel
    03.28 / 21:25 hamodia.com
    Defense Minister Avigdor Liberman hinted on Tuesday that he would support a pardon for IDF soldier Elor Azaria, who was convicted in January of manslaughter in the killing of a… Read more » The post Liberman May Support Pardon for Elor Azaria appeared first on Hamodia. In related news: Polls Call for Azaria Pardon, But Liberman Unimpressed OPINION: A Pardon for Elor Azaria After Sentencing, Ministers, MKs Demand Pardon for Azaria MKs, Angry Israelis Demand Pardon for Azaria…
  2. MK Glick Petitions High Court Over Har HaBayis Ban

    Hamodia.com - Israel
    03.28 / 21:11 hamodia.com
    The Israeli High Court may soon be drawn into a dispute over a government ban on Knesset members visiting the Har HaBayis. The Jerusalem Post reports that MK Yehudah Glick… Read more » The post MK Glick Petitions High Court Over Har HaBayis Ban appeared first on Hamodia. In related news: Yaalon Resignation Fallout: Right-Wing Yehuda Glick to Become MK Har Habayis Ban Extended for MKs Glick’s Condition Slowly Improving Netanyahu Lambastes Abbas Over Letter To Glick A…
  3. Pres. Trump Promises Move on Peace ‘Very Soon’

    Hamodia.com - Israel
    03.28 / 20:13 hamodia.com
    The Trump administration is actively seeking a renewal of Israeli-Palestinian peace talks in the near term, according to a flurry of media reports in Israel on Tuesday night. However, the… Read more » The post Pres. Trump Promises Move on Peace ‘Very Soon’ appeared first on Hamodia. In related news: Abbas: ‘A Historic Peace Deal Is Possible’ ANALYSIS: In Week of Middle East Talks, Trump Envoy Avoids Disruption Embassy Move Stirs Palestinian…
  4. Extra Iron Dome Launchers on New Missile Ships

    Hamodia.com - Israel
    03.28 / 16:59 hamodia.com
    Following intelligence estimates of a growing rocket threat to Israel’s offshore energy assets, the Navy has decided to equip its new Sa’ar-6 missile carriers under construction in Germany with twice… Read more » The post Extra Iron Dome Launchers on New Missile Ships appeared first on Hamodia. In related news: Rafael to Present Advanced Combat Systems And Naval Iron Dome at Paris Exhibit Canada to Get Iron Dome Radar Technology Iron Dome Agreement Allows Immediate Transfer o…
  5. New Missile Ships Fitted With Extra Iron Dome Launchers

    Hamodia.com - Israel
    03.28 / 16:45 hamodia.com
    Following intelligence estimates of a growing rocket threat to Israel’s offshore energy assets, the Navy has decided to equip its new Sa’ar-6 missile carriers under construction in Germany with twice… Read more » The post New Missile Ships Fitted With Extra Iron Dome Launchers appeared first on Hamodia. In related news: Rafael to Present Advanced Combat Systems And Naval Iron Dome at Paris Exhibit Canada to Get Iron Dome Radar Technology Iron Dome Agreement Allows Immediate T…
  6. American Jews, which side are you on?

    972mag.com - Israel
    03.28 / 16:03 972mag.com
    Rather than sit uncomfortably within the tired anti- or pro-Israel paradigm, we are building a reality in which American Jews who disagree with the occupation can take comfort in their Jewish identity. By Shira Yudkin Tiffany Rows of police demarcated the sides outside the annual AIPAC Policy Conference in Washington D.C. Two human chains of protestors in matching t-shirts [&#…
  7. The cultural terrorism of Miri Regev

    972mag.com - Israel
    03.28 / 16:03 972mag.com
    By threatening the livelihood of Palestinian theater workers, Regev is committing cultural terrorism: she is putting people’s livelihoods at risk — people whose only sin is holding different political principles than her. In an interview Monday morning, Culture Minister Miri Regev revealed her true intentions to Army Radio host Razi Barkai: she wishes to shut down Al-Midan, the […
  8. Hamas Develops Powerful New Rockets, Threatening Israeli Towns Near Gaza

    Thetower.org - Israel
    03.28 / 15:45 thetower.org
    The Palestinian terrorist group Hamas has acquired new, more powerful rockets that could severely threaten Israeli towns near the Gaza Strip, Army Radio reported Tuesday. The rockets carry hundreds of kilograms of explosive material and have a short range of a few kilometers, similar to the range of mortar shells, according to an assessment by the …
  9. RyanAir Begins Ben Gurion Flights Tuesday

    Hamodia.com - Israel
    03.28 / 14:36 hamodia.com
    Travel history is to be made in Israel Tuesday night, as Ben Gurion airport hosts its first departure of a RyanAir flight. The low-cost line’s maiden voyage will be to… Read more » The post RyanAir Begins Ben Gurion Flights Tuesday appeared first on Hamodia. In related news: Low-Cost Carrier Ryanair to Land in Israel RyanAir to Take ‘Summer Break’ From Israel Ryanair Flight Encounters Two IAF Planes, Disputes Report of ‘Near-Crash’ RyanAir…
  10. ANALYSIS: Political, Regional Clouds Gather Over Israel Even as Economy Booms

    Hamodia.com - Israel
    03.28 / 13:53 hamodia.com
    Israel’s politics are darkening: the governing coalition, in power for barely two years, is in tumult and regional tensions are rising. Looking only at the economy, things seem bright. U.S.… Read more » The post ANALYSIS: Political, Regional Clouds Gather Over Israel Even as Economy Booms appeared first on Hamodia. In related news: Israel Carries Out Second Round of Strikes on Gaza After Hezbollah Threat, Lebanese President ‘Warns’ Israel Lebanon’s…
  11. AIPAC Kicks Off With U.S., UK, Canadian & Rwandan Leaders Praising Israel Ties

    Thetower.org - Israel
    03.28 / 12:28 thetower.org
    Sunday marked the start of AIPAC’s annual policy conference held in Washington, with a former UK Prime Minister warning of the Iranian threat to the region at the opening session. Tony Blair appeared at the opening session of the conference, whilst U.S. Vice President Mike Pence, Israeli Ambassador to the U.S. Ron Dermer, and President […
  12. Israeli Air Force Begins Joint Exercise with U.S., UAE, Italy, Greece

    Thetower.org - Israel
    03.28 / 12:28 thetower.org
    Israeli fighter planes began multinational exercises in Greece on Monday alongside jets from multiple other countries, including the United States, United Arab Emirates, and Italy. The Iniohos 2017 exercise, which is being hosted at Greece’s Andravida Air Base, featured a commemorative patch including the flags of all five participating nations. “Multinational training engagements such as these …
  13. UN Ambassador Haley: “The Days of Israel-Bashing Are Over”

    Thetower.org - Israel
    03.28 / 12:28 thetower.org
    When it comes to combatting anti-Israel bias at the United Nations, “there’s a new sheriff in town,” United States Ambassador to the UN Nikki Haley proclaimed on Monday at the AIPAC Policy Conference. Haley cited two episodes that demonstrated her commitment to protecting Israel from unfair attacks. First, she recalled how she blocked the appointment…
  14. As Palestinian divisions deepen, Arab actors seek two-state alternative

    972mag.com - Israel
    03.28 / 12:17 972mag.com
    Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas is worried that ‘regional peace’ would prompt normalization between Arab states and Israel, while sidelining the two-state solution. Yet increasingly, Palestinian and Arab actors are pursuing a number of alternative solutions to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. By Ella Aphek During Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu’s last visit to Washington, President Trump introduced a [R…
  15. Assault on Palestinian man shows violent effects of police impunity

    972mag.com - Israel
    03.28 / 12:17 972mag.com
    Even when brutality is documented, Palestinians must live with the knowledge that they are unlikely to receive truth, justice, or respect from the authorities that claim to serve them. In the wake of a video released last Thursday showing an Israeli police officer assaulting a Palestinian truck driver in East Jerusalem, Police Commissioner Roni Alsheikh…
  16. Political poetry as a crime: Inside the surreal trial of Dareen Tatour

    972mag.com - Israel
    03.28 / 12:17 972mag.com
    Arresting a Palestinian for publishing a political poem is extraordinary. Having to prove at trial that police mistranslated her poem is nothing short of surreal. By Yoav Haifawi It has been nearly a year and a half since Palestinian poet Dareen Tatour was arrested in her home in northern Israel for writing a poem. She spent three months in [&#…
  17. As an Israeli soldier, I played God with Palestinians

    972mag.com - Israel
    03.28 / 12:17 972mag.com
    The occupation allows us to demand Palestinians show their identification cards at a whim. It allows us to slap, shove, or shoot them if necessary — even if they are the same age as our fathers or young enough to be our children. By Alon Mizrahi Only last night, once I sat down after a long day, did the memories come [……
  18. ‘There’s an opportunity to embed Palestine in the progressive agenda’

    972mag.com - Israel
    03.28 / 12:17 972mag.com
    A lot of smart people thought Barak Obama would be more sympathetic than his predecessors to the Palestinian cause, hopefully resulting in a more even-handed approach to the conflict. Obama, however, along with Hillary Clinton and John Kerry, failed to achieve peace and things on the ground in Israel/Palestine are measurably worse today than they…
  19. Year after Dafna Meir’s murder, husband gets engaged

    Jerusalemonline.com - Israel
    03.28 / 12:17 jerusalemonline.com
    Natan Meir, who lost his wife Dafna in the Otniel terror attack in January 2016, announced last night that he is…
  20. Largest dinosaur footprint discovered in Australia

    Jerusalemonline.com - Israel
    03.28 / 12:17 jerusalemonline.com
    Researchers in Australia announced that they have found the largest dinosaur footprint in the world, measuring at approximately 1.75 meters (about 5 feet, 9 inches) long in the area dubbed Australias Jurassic Park. “This area preserves one of the most diverse dinosaur track fauna anywhere in the w…