‘Calling BS’ class at UW popular


‘Calling BS’ class at UW popular
  1. ‘Calling BS’ class at UW popular
    columbian.com
    SEATTLE — Did you hear about the researchers in China who said they’d developed an algorithm that could predict whether somebody was a criminal by scanning a photo of their fac…
    Washington (WA)

SEATTLE — Did you hear about the researchers in China who said they’d developed an algorithm that could predict whether somebody was a criminal by scanning a photo of their face?

The researchers used “fancy machine learning” to eliminate human biases and come up with a scientific way to determine criminality by examining facial features, University of Washington professor Carl Bergstrom told his class in Mary Gates Hall one day last month.

“What do you guys think?” Bergstrom asked.

In unison, more than 100 students responded out loud: “Bulls—!”

Exactly.

Biology professor Bergstrom and Information School professor Jevin West are co-teaching a seminar this quarter that’s all about BS — or, precisely, “Calling BS in the Age of Big Data.”

The 10-week seminar class has achieved the academic version of a chart-topping pop single: At the UW, it reached its 160-student capacity shortly after registration opened this spring.

Its reach across the globe is even more impressive. Colleges in Canada, France, Portugal, England and Australia have contacted the professors about teaching a version of the course this fall. A partial list: Carnegie Mellon University, Hofstra College, Iowa State University, Stanford University, Columbia University, UCLA, Oxford University (England), Universite de Nantes (France), Murdoch University (Australia), University of Guelph (Canada) and Instituto Piaget (Portugal).

Currently, a Catholic high-school teacher in Minnesota and a tech college in Copenhagen are teaching the course, and the University of Alaska Anchorage will teach it this fall.

The course syllabus is freely available, as are YouTube videos of the lectures.

West and Bergstrom are especially enthusiastic about helping high school teachers use the BS course materials to develop classes.

“Ultimately, that’s very important to us, because this is material that shouldn’t wait until your senior year of college,” West said.

The professors attracted widespread attention by using a profanity in the title of the course, but the interest is real. So far, the first video of their class lecture has been viewed more than 12,000 times.

Calling BS is not a class about fake news, and it’s not a political science course. Rather, the professors want students to develop a skeptical eye about big data and its limitations, particularly in the sciences. They’re teaching how to recognize results that are just too good to be true.

In their fifth lecture, Bergstrom and West explored why Google’s much-vaunted ability to predict a flu outbreak turned out to be, well, BS.

They picked apart the Chinese criminality project. They examined the mystery of why — with the exception of Sept. 11 — the 11th day of the month is referenced less frequently in books and literature than almost any other day of the month, at least as measured in a Google book-scanning project.(Think you know the answer? Read to the end.)

One of their main themes: If the data collected for use in an analysis isn’t solid, the result won’t be, either. “Garbage in, garbage out,” West told the class.

In the case of the algorithm that claimed to predict criminality, the Chinese researchers used pictures of incarcerated and innocent people to create a mathematical formula to identify people in each category.

But, as Bergstrom noted, the non-criminals were wearing faint smiles; the criminals had subtle frowns etched into their faces. “I have this hypothesis that this is a smile detector,” he told the class.

As for Google Flu Trends — Google’s instantaneous map of influenza hot spots, created using the geographic locations of searches for flu-like symptoms — the company appeared to be predicting outbreaks as much as two weeks faster than the Centers for Disease Control, which relied on confirmed reports of influenza from doctors and medical centers.

“When I read this article, I remember taking it to my class and saying, ‘Big data really is amazing,'” West said. “Big data is changing the world.”

But Google Flu Trends soon became the poster child of big-data hubris and overreach, West said. As time ticked…

  1. CDC widens relief efforts as list of affected areas grows

    Stabroeknews.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:58 stabroeknews.com
    The Civil Defence Com-mission (CDC) was yesterday preparing to extend its surveillance and relief efforts as it received reports of more flood-affected areas in regions 8 and 7. The post CDC widens... View full article at…
  2. GuySuCo warns it may be forced to close Uitvlugt estate

    Stabroeknews.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:58 stabroeknews.com
    The Guyana Sugar Corporation (GuySuCo) has said that if the 375 cane-harvesters and cane-transporters of the Wales estate do not support the Uitvlugt Improvement Programme (UIP), it may be forced to... View full article at…
  3. Trio to stand trial for murder of Hill Foot farmer

    Stabroeknews.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:58 stabroeknews.com
    The three accused in the murder of Hill Foot farmer Anthony Breedy were yesterday committed to stand trial by a city court, and one of them later went on a rampage in the courtyard, where he... View full article at…
  4. GBTI to recover funds lost in alleged fraud -Board Chairman

    Stabroeknews.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:58 stabroeknews.com
    Shareholders of the Guyana Bank for Trade and Industry (GBTI) were last evening assured that the bank would recover the $941 million lost in a fraudulent transaction allegedly conducted by gold... View full article at…
  5. Spokane Police say missing 10-year-old boy found safe

    Myfoxspokane.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:54 myfoxspokane.com
    Update: Spokane Police say 10-year-old Jeremy Clough has been found and is safe as…
  6. UK police treating Ariana Grande concert blast as terrorism

    Myfoxspokane.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:54 myfoxspokane.com
    By JO KEARNEY, GREGORY KATZ and JILL LAWLESSAssociated Press MANCHESTER, England (AP) – An…
  7. Police raise toll to 22 at Ariana Grande concert

    Myfoxspokane.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:54 myfoxspokane.com
    The Latest on the explosion at an Ariana Grande concert in Manchester, England (all…
  8. The Latest: police say apparent suicide bomber set of blast

    Myfoxspokane.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:54 myfoxspokane.com
    MANCHESTER, England (AP) – The Latest on the blast at an Ariana Grande concert…
  9. Woman killed when boat strikes Interstate 205 Bridge

    Columbian.com - Vancouver
    05.23 / 06:52 columbian.com
    A woman was killed after her boat rammed into one of the pylons under the Interstate 205 Bridge Monday…
  10. MTHS athletes to compete for WIAA state titles

    Mltnews.com  - Halls Lake
    05.23 / 06:45 mltnews.com
    It’s high school spring sports championship week and fans can find Mountlake Terrace student athletes competing for WIAA state titles all over Washington State. Here’s the rundown of Hawks vying for state championships this week. WIAA 2A State Track & Field Championships Thursday, May 25 – Saturday, May 27 Mount Tahoma High School, Tacoma Madison [R…
  11. South County Politics: Candidate filing brings big fields in Fire District 1, Edmonds School District

    Mltnews.com  - Halls Lake
    05.23 / 06:45 mltnews.com
    Candidate filing ended Friday for local races, with several positions having enough candidates to force a primary — and the race for a place in Snohomish County Fire District 1 has the biggest field. Voters in unincorporated areas of South Snohomish County will have five candidates for a single place on the board of Fire…
  12. 2017 Development Update: Focus Shifts To By the Ballpark, At Last

    Jdland.com - Washington (WA)
    05.23 / 06:39 jdland.com
    While I was on the roof of F1rst earlier this week, the view to the west was striking. Immediately north of Nats Park, with the long-forlorn block of Half Street between the Center Field Gate and the Metro station running down the middle of the frame, my camera spied:* The first piles being driven for JBG's West Half residential and retail project; * Some evidence of initial activity at Monument Valley, where Jair Lynch's 1250 Half Street residential and retail project is set to finally…
  13. Warriors, Mavs set sights on state championships this week

    Myedmondsnews.com - Edmonds
    05.23 / 06:31 myedmondsnews.com
    It’s high school spring sports championship week and fans can find Edmonds-Woodway and Meadowdale student athletes competing for WIAA state titles all over Washington state. Here’s the rundown of Warriors and Mavericks vying for state championships this week. WIAA 3A State Boys Golf Championship Tuesday, May 23 – Wednesday, May 24 Columbia Point Golf Course, [R…
  14. 22 Dead, Dozens Injured After Explosion At Ariana Grande Concert

    Seattle.cbslocal.com - Seattle
    05.23 / 06:30 seattle.cbslocal.com
    Authorities are currently treating it as a terrorist…
  15. Meadowdale, Lynnwood athletes to compete for WIAA state titles

    Lynnwoodtoday.com-WA
    05.23 / 06:28 lynnwoodtoday.com
    It’s high school spring sports championship week and fans can find Meadowdale and Lynnwood student athletes competing for WIAA state titles all over Washington State. Here’s the rundown of Mavericks and Royals vying for state championships this week. WIAA 3A State Boys Golf Championship Tuesday, May 23 – Wednesday, May 24 Columbia Point Golf Course, [R…
  16. South County Politics: Candidate filing brings big fields in Fire District 1, Edmonds School District

    Lynnwoodtoday.com-WA
    05.23 / 06:28 lynnwoodtoday.com
    Candidate filing ended Friday for local races, with several positions having enough candidates to force a primary — and the race for a place in Snohomish County Fire District 1 has the biggest field. Voters in unincorporated areas of South Snohomish County will have five candidates for a single place on the board of Fire…
  17. Longview motor company expanding into new plant

    Tdn.com-WA
    05.23 / 06:28 tdn.com
    Sales at a Longview electric motor business have revved up in recent years, and it’s building more space to grow even f…
  18. Economic growth, taxes key priorities for port candidates

    Tdn.com-WA
    05.23 / 06:28 tdn.com
    The Port of Longview commission race this year will have a familiar cast of characters, with an incumbent Doug Averett vying to hold his seat against a Castle Rock military contractor, Kent Preston, who has twice tried to land…
  19. Rick Roberson won't seek reelection to Kelso Council

    Tdn.com-WA
    05.23 / 06:28 tdn.com
    Kelso Councilman Rick Roberson ended his re-election bid Monday, leaving a decade of service behind and two challengers contending for his…
  20. Longview homeless man threatens bar patrons with sword

    Tdn.com-WA
    05.23 / 06:28 tdn.com
    Patrons of the Maltese Bar and Grill in Kelso told police that a transient man was waving a sword across the street Sunday afternoon and that he has mental health…