Don't trust the list prices on Amazon, Consumer Watchdog says


Don't trust the list prices on Amazon, Consumer Watchdog says
  1. Don't trust the list prices on Amazon, Consumer Watchdog says
    dailypilot.com
    After a barrage of lawsuits directed at the online shopping industry, it appeared Amazon Inc. was quietly phasing out list pricing, a controversial practice accused of deceptively inflating how much consumers save through the e-commerce giant. But a study commissioned by Consumer Watchdog…
    Education & Family

After a barrage of lawsuits directed at the online shopping industry, it appeared Amazon Inc. was quietly phasing out list pricing, a controversial practice accused of deceptively inflating how much consumers save through the e-commerce giant.

But a study commissioned by Consumer Watchdog finds that the pricing system remains widely used, affecting more than a quarter of the 4,000 products examined by the advocacy group on Amazon.com.

List prices are a familiar sight to most online shoppers: crossed-out price tags displayed alongside the current, cheaper cost. The larger the difference between the two, the more likely consumers will be drawn to buying the item.

The problem is that few know how Amazon determines the list price, which critics say could be arbitrarily inflated to create the appearance of a steeper discount. The company says on its website that list pricemeans the suggested retail price of a product as provided by a manufacturer, supplier or seller.”

In a statement, Amazon called the Consumer Watchdog report misleading.

“Manufacturers, vendors and sellers provide list prices, but our customers care about how the price they are paying compares to other retailers,” the company said. “We validate list prices against actual prices recently found across Amazon and other retailers, and we eliminate List Price when we believe it isn’t relevant to our customers.”

The company said it has also introduced a “was” price using recent price history of the product on Amazon. That provides customers with “an alternative reference price when we don’t display List Price,” the statement said.

In its study, Consumer Watchdog said it found at least half the list prices examined were greater than the prevailing market price.

“There’s no real transparency about what the heck they’re doing,” said John M. Simpson, privacy project director for Consumer Watchdog, which filed a petition Monday calling on California Atty. Gen. Xavier Becerra to investigate Amazon. “At a minimum, there needs to be some clear understanding about how they’re coming up with these purported list prices.”

The practice has garnered widespread attention in recent years after a number of lawsuits against retailers.

In 2014, Amazon rival Overstock was fined $6.8 million by a California judge for misstating its sale prices. That same year, a still-pending class action suit was launched in California against Amazon over its list prices.

More recently, Amazon was fined about $750,000 in January by Canada’s Competition Bureau for misleading savings claims. Amazon voluntarily changed its pricing practice in Canada prior to the bureau’s fine.

Bricks-and-mortar stores have also been accused of misleading pricing practices. In December, the Los Angeles city attorney’s office sued JC Penney, Sears, Kohl’s and Macy’s, accusing them of falsely advertising lofty discounts.

“Unfortunately, this sales tactic or fictitious pricing actually works and retailers know that,” said Bonnie Patten, executive director of Truth in Advertising, a consumer advocacy group unaffiliated with the Consumer Watchdog study. “It’s not just Amazon.”

All retailers are required under state and federal law to display reference prices that reflect how much an item is generally sold for. This can be determined a number of ways, including looking at the average prices for any particular item, the median price or even the most commonly used price in order to build a comparison.

Not knowing precisely how Amazon comes up with its numbers, Consumer Watchdog compared the 4,000 products in its study with competitors’ prices to determine if they reflect the average, median or most common prices on the market. What it found was that none of these measures was likely a determining factor.

It couldn’t have been average because 71% of the products picked for the study had more expensive list prices than competitors’ sale prices. It couldn’t have been median either after the group found 74% of the items were listed at a greater cost than the median prices offered by competitors. Lastly, it was unlikely Amazon used the most common prices since more than half the products in the study were listed at a higher cost compared with those at competitors.

Amazon’s list prices “were an entirely bogus notional price that created the false impression that customers were getting a deal when they were not,” Simpson wrote in his petition to the state attorney general.

In its study, Consumer Watchdog provided several examples of what it believed were misleadingly priced products. Among them, a Chicago Pneumatic brand power drill going for $182.99, an apparent steep discount from its list price of $305. However, the same tool could be found for the same price at Jet.com. Walmart and Zoro.com, a building supply site, sold the drill for $189.99.

In another example, Amazon was selling an Acer 12-inch laptop with a crossed-out list price of $799. Acer, however, sells the same device on its website for $749.99.

Caption 90 seconds: 4 stories you can't miss

The L.A. Marathon was a serious athletic event -- with a festive twist. Judge Neil Gorsuch faces his first day of confirmation hearings. What happened to Ivanka Trump, the liberal hope of the Trump administration? A mother’s search for her son has finally ended at a mass grave in Veracruz, Mexico.

The L.A. Marathon was a serious athletic event -- with a festive twist. Judge Neil Gorsuch faces his first day of confirmation hearings. What happened to Ivanka Trump, the liberal hope of the Trump administration? A mother’s search for her son has finally ended at a mass grave in Veracruz, Mexico.

Caption 90 seconds: 4 stories you can't miss

The L.A. Marathon was a serious athletic event -- with a festive twist. Judge Neil Gorsuch faces his first day of confirmation hearings. What happened to Ivanka Tru…

  1. Sense of others, sense of self

    Yaleherald.com - Education & Family
    03.24 / 10:37 yaleherald.com
    According to Linda Honan, a longtime professor at YSN, this is a pretty common phenomenon: people do not see the same way. And while this has few implications on a leisurely museum visit—so what if you missed the hand?—for nursing students this isn’t a day off…
  2. Wins and flosses

    Yaleherald.com - Education & Family
    03.24 / 10:37 yaleherald.com
    In 2013, the American Dental Association found that 50.5% of Americans surveyed floss daily, and 30% floss but not…
  3. Hard times at McAuley, Mercy revealed

    Wcpo.com - Education & Family
    03.24 / 10:23 wcpo.com
    Since 2008, a huge decline in enrollment at McAuley and a smaller but significant decline at Mother of Mercy had bled the schools financially and prompted an infusion of  millions of dollars from the Sisters of Me…
  4. Why spring break means no food for some kids

    Wcpo.com - Education & Family
    03.24 / 10:23 wcpo.com
    For thousands of kids who attend Cincinnati Public Schools, spring break will mean no homework, no tests -- and no reliable source of food until classes start…
  5. Man grateful for free manufacturing training

    SFgate.com-Education
    03.24 / 10:04 sfgate.com
    Lindsey, a line operator in his fifth year at Primex Plastics in Richmond, participated in the Manufacturing Matters program. Local men and women can now sign up for five weeks of training for advanced manufacturing opportunities. The training is free to qualified applicants, thanks to support from partners including local employers, Ivy Tech Community College and WorkOne. The registration deadline has been extended to March 31 for Manufacturing Matters' production associate…
  6. Rachel Dolezal struggles after racial identity scandal

    Collegian.psu.edu - Education
    03.24 / 09:27 collegian.psu.edu
    SPOKANE, Wash. (AP) — A woman who rose to prominence as a black civil rights leader then lost her job when her parents exposed her as white is struggling to make a living these d…
  7. House sets risky health care vote after Trump demands it

    Collegian.psu.edu - Education
    03.24 / 09:27 collegian.psu.edu
    WASHINGTON (AP) — In a gamble with monumental political stakes, Republicans set course for a climactic House vote on their health care overhaul after President Donald Trump claimed he was finished negotiating with GOP holdouts and determined to pursue t…
  8. After Delaying Vote, GOP Leaders Scramble To Save Health Care Bill

    Wprl.org - Education
    03.24 / 08:46 wprl.org
    Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit KELLY MCEVERS, HOST: Republican leaders in Washington are scrambling to save their bill to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act. The House of Representatives was supposed to vote on the health care bill today, but with Republicans divided over just how far they should go with their changes, the vote was postponed. NPR congressional correspondent Susan Davis is following all this at the Capitol. Hi there, Sue. SUSAN DAVIS, BYLINE: Hey, Kelly.…
  9. House Postpones Vote On Republican Health Care Bill

    Wprl.org - Education
    03.24 / 08:46 wprl.org
    Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit KELLY MCEVERS, HOST: And to help us understand what's happening on Capitol Hill tonight, I am joined by NPR's Ron Elving. Hello there, Ron. RON ELVING, BYLINE: Good to be with you, Kelly. MCEVERS: So tonight the president threatened that if the House does not vote on this tomorrow and does not pass their own health care bill, that he is going to move on and leave Obamacare in place. How serious a threat is that do you think? ELVING: It sounds pretty…
  10. This Week In Race: ICE Sends Chills Across US, Kaepernick, Others, Write Big Checks

    Wprl.org - Education
    03.24 / 08:46 wprl.org
    Oh people: it's been one of those weeks again. The focus on immigration continues, as the government promises to punish sanctuary cities and cities that have chosen not to do ICE's work for it by detaining undocumented immigrants until that agency can collect them for deportation. A number of police departments, including the LAPD, have indicated widespread fear of deportation in immigrant communities has had deleterious effects on how the police do their jobs. Stories like this one just…
  11. California fuel standards to get critical review

    Collegian.psu.edu - Education
    03.24 / 08:22 collegian.psu.edu
    RIVERSIDE, Calif. (AP) — A state review has found California is on track to meet its tougher car-emission standards and urges regulators to draft more ambitious environmental targets for the f…
  12. Jordan-Shockley, Sammy-Jorge UPUA executive tickets campaign at second 'Meet the Candidates' session

    Collegian.psu.edu - Education
    03.24 / 08:22 collegian.psu.edu
    The second UPUA "Meet the Candidates" session saw an uptick in general student…
  13. Meet the 2017-18 UPUA executive tickets: Samantha Geisinger and Katie Jordan running for president

    Collegian.psu.edu - Education
    03.24 / 08:22 collegian.psu.edu
    Leading up to the UPUA election, here's a little bit more about those running for this year's executive ticket. This is the first in a four-part…
  14. Maryland high school thrust into immigration debate

    Collegian.psu.edu - Education
    03.24 / 08:22 collegian.psu.edu
    BETHESDA, Md. (AP) — Outside a Maryland high school dragged into the national immigration debate by an alleged rape, a makeshift sign reflects that strain: "Rockville S…
  15. 8 Things To Do in Your Queens Neighborhood This Weekend

    Dnainfo.com - Education & Family
    03.24 / 08:09 dnainfo.com
    Catch a kid-friendly concert, enjoy an afternoon tea social or take a nighttime tour of a historic …
  16. 'Alien' haunts outer space thriller 'Life'

    Dailypilot.com - Education & Family
    03.24 / 08:04 dailypilot.com
    Say hello to Calvin. Or maybe not. Calvin is the resident alien on space station Plymouth Rock and really, he would as soon suck the life out of you as look at you. Calvin comes from Mars, if you must know, but in truth his talents for havoc and devastation were wasted on the cold, dead Red…
  17. New presidents or provosts: D'Youville Earlham Free State Harford JMU Rhodes Southwestern UNI UNT-Dallas Walsh

    Insidehighered.com -Education
    03.24 / 07:56 www.insidehighered.com
    Lorrie Clemo, provost and vice president for academic affairs at the State University of New York College at Oswego, has been selected as president of D'Youville College, also in New York. Heather Coltman, dean of the Dorothy F. Schmidt College of Arts and Letters at Florida Atlantic University, has been appointed provost and senior vice president for academic affairs at James Madison University, in Virginia. Marjorie Hass, president of Austin College, in Texas, has been named…
  18. The peace process and higher education in Colombia

    Insidehighered.com - Education
    03.24 / 07:53 insidehighered.com
    On Nov. 24, 2016, the great and the good of Colombian higher education made their way through Bogotá’s noise, congestion and pollution, past the graffiti murals of exotic birds, serpents and mythological scenes, to a plush reception hosted by the U.S. Embassy. The occasion was a Thanksgiving lunch. But the Colombians could surely have been forgiven if they preferred to give thanks not so much for the American harvest as for the dividend they hope to reap from the…
  19. Indiana creates free tuition program for certificate earners

    Insidehighered.com - Education
    03.24 / 07:53 insidehighered.com
    When people talk about free community college, they’re most likely thinking about tuition-free programs like those in Tennessee or the one proposed by President Obama, which focus on getting students to an associate degree with as little debt as possible. But in Indiana, a new proposal -- the Workforce Ready Grant -- would instead offer free community college to those students who want a certificate in a high-demand field. While the certificates would vary by program, they…
  20. Head of McGill's Canadian studies institute resigns after column offensive to some Quebecers

    Insidehighered.com - Education
    03.24 / 07:53 insidehighered.com
    The director of McGill University’s Institute for the Study of Canada has resigned from his post after a magazine column he wrote about "social malaise" in Quebec came under heavy criticism, including from the province’s premier. In announcing his resignation on social media, Andrew Potter, a former newspaper editor with a Ph.D. in philosophy from the University of Toronto, cited “the ongoing negative reaction within the university community and the broader public to…