Supreme Court likely to boost public schools' responsibilities to children with disabilities

Supreme Court likely to boost public schools' responsibilities to children with disabilities
  1. Supreme Court likely to boost public schools' responsibilities to children with disabilities
    Supreme Court justices appeared ready Wednesday to clarify and strengthen the rights of the nation’s 6.7 million children with disabilities, perhaps by requiring public schools to offer a special education program that will ensure they can make significant progress. The case of a Colorado boy wi…

Supreme Court justices appeared ready Wednesday to clarify and strengthen the rights of the nation’s 6.7 million children with disabilities, perhaps by requiring public schools to offer a special education program that will ensure they can make significant progress.

The case of a Colorado boy with autism, Endrew F. vs. Douglas County School District, could have a far-reaching impact on millions of children and their parents as well as the budgets of school districts nationwide.

At issue is a long-standing federal law that says children with disabilities have a right to a “free appropriate public education.” Schools, courts and parents have been divided over what this promise means in practice.

Does it mean, for example, that a school must merely offer a minimal special program that may offer “some educational benefit” to the child, as a federal appeals court in Denver ruled? Or instead, do these children have a right to “make significant educational progress,” as lawyers for the outgoing Obama administration contend.

During Wednesday’s argument, the justices struggled with the lawyers and among themselves to find the right legal standard. At one point, Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. drew knowing smiles from his colleagues when he complained of  the “blizzard of words” being tossed around, most of which had no clear meaning. 

However, most of the justices appeared to favor setting a slightly higher standard, one that should lead the child to make measured progress on academics or behavior.  Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. said it would not be sufficient for schools to provide an expert for five minutes a day and claim they were providing the child “some benefit.”

But the chief justice and others said they were wary of setting an unrealistically strict standard that would require students meet certain goals. They also voiced worries about costs and an explosion of lawsuits.

Parents who are dissatisfied with the special educational program may remove their child from the public school, enroll him or her in a private school and then sue to have the costs paid by the school district. But to win a reimbursement, the parents must show that the public school failed to provide the “appropriate” education promised by the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.

A coalition of big-city school districts, including the Los Angeles Unified School District, warned the high court of the growing cost of private programs, which on average are more than four times as expensive as a public program. Los Angeles school officials said they spend $93 million a year on these private placements.

In the case before the court, the parents of Endrew F., an autistic child from Douglas County, Colo., enrolled him in public school through 4th grade. They worked with teachers to devise a special education program for him, but by fourth grade, his behavior was getting worse. He had repeated outbursts in class, banged his head on the floor and twice ran away from the school.

His parents moved him to a private school where he was “thriving,” according to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals. Nonetheless, the judges ruled the public school system need not reimburse the parents because it had provided their child with a minimally “adequate” educational program. “It is not the [school] district’s burden to pay for his placement [in the private school] when Drew was…

  1. Whitney: Memo to President Trump - Companies
    01.20 / 04:30
    As inauguration takes shape, words of wisdom for Commander in Chief who takes over divided and fearful…
  2. Video shows police cornering mentally ill man and fatally shooting him: 'This was an execution'

    01.19 / 06:01
    Graphic surveillance video released Wednesday shows a throng of Fontana police officers surrounding a legally blind and mentally ill man in a convenience store before an officer opens fire, killing him. The muted video of the Nov. 22, 2015, incident shows multiple police officers cornering…
  3. Tailoring your integration approach to specific deals - Companies
    01.19 / 03:03
    Every merger or acquisition is different, yet many companies stick to the same integration playbook. Here’s how to tailor your a…
  4. Baby raccoons recover at Oakland Zoo after accidental cross-country ride

    01.19 / 02:58
    Baby raccoons that inadvertently hitched a cross-country ride to Northern California are recovering at the Oakland Zoo. Animal care authorities said this week that a man had unknowingly transported the raccoons from Florida to Marin County in September in a moving truck. The truck had been…
  5. Clippers regroup while Chris Paul recovers from thumb surgery

    01.19 / 01:44
    J.J. Redick stood with his back against the wall before practice and stared straight ahead as he contemplated playing basketball without Chris Paul, while the All-Star point guard recovers from surgery he had Wednesday to repair a torn ligament in his left thumb. The two Clippers guards…
  6. United thins management ranks

    CNNMoney - Companies
    01.18 / 23:54
    United Airlines last week tightened its belt, laying off some high-ranking managers, as it progressed deeper into its corporate makeover. …
  7. Convenience store clerk stabbed to death in Rapid City, suspects identified - Companies
    01.18 / 23:39
    Two teenagers suspected of stabbing to death a convenience store clerk in Rapid City are in custody, police…
  8. PET recycler US Fibers expanding in South Carolina - Companies
    01.18 / 22:21
    Recycled polyester fiber maker US Fibers is expanding in South Carolina, a move that will create more than 20…
  9. Cisco loses a round on forcing an employee into arbitration

    01.18 / 21:27
    Big companies love to force their legal adversaries into arbitration, especially when those adversaries are employees, customers, or others without money or power, and therefore are at a disadvantage. Judges usually love arbitration too, because it relieves them of the chore of overseeing…
  10. Braskem opens Texas UHMWPE plant - Companies
    01.18 / 21:07
    Braskem SA has opened a new plant making Utec-brand ultra-high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) in LaPorte,…
  11. RPA names new leadership - Companies
    01.18 / 19:16
    Norm Kukuk, executive vice president of marketing for Orbis Corp., takes over as chairman of the Reusable Packaging Association after serving as vice chairman last…
  12. Grupo Ortiz plans first plants outside Mexico - Companies
    01.18 / 18:04
    Grupo Industrial Ortiz, which claims to be the world's largest producer of polypropylene raffia woven sacks and similar products, is diversifying into food packaging and disposable tableware and preparing to invest outside Mexico for the first…
  13. Viking Plastics' Brazilian JV expands capacity - Companies
    01.18 / 18:03
    São Paulo-based Injequaly Indústria e Comércio Ltda., a joint venture between the Brazilian plastic injection molding company and the U.S. firm Viking Plastics, is moving to a larger facility in Brazil to expand production after its sales went up 51…
  14. Jim Jarmusch, Ron Padgett and the sublime poetry of 'Paterson'

    01.18 / 17:46
    Poetry flows through Jim Jarmusch’s latest film, “Paterson,” in much the same way that the Passaic River winds through the titular New Jersey city, before gracefully dropping over the Great Falls. The initial effect is subtle, but the lasting impression is sublime.  The film’s protagonist, a self-effacin…
  15. Pearson plunges as digital switch forces new profit warning

    CNBC - Companies
    01.18 / 17:37
    The world's biggest education company is facing turmoil as customers turn to cheaper digital alternatives, or choose to rent instead of buy…
  16. What We're Reading: Top State Stories 1/18 - Companies
    01.18 / 16:56
    Texas House Speaker Joe Straus’ $108.9 billion spending plan for the 2018-19 state budget would boost public school funding by $1.5 billion above the cost of enrollment growth and add $268 million for Child Protective Services and $162 million for mental health…
  17. RPM International makes fourth acquisition of 2017 - Companies
    01.18 / 16:49
    RPM International acquired Conyers, Ga.-based Prime Resins to be part of its USL Group. Prime Resins produces specialty chemicals and equipment for infrastructure construction and repair. It reported annual net sales of about $7…
  18. Weak holiday sales force Target to drop 4Q earnings forecast

    CNBC - Companies
    01.18 / 16:23
    The company said comparable sales declined 1.3 percent in the November-December…
  19. Campaign Art: Food Waste - Companies
    01.18 / 15:42
    People, Spaces, Deliberation bloggers present exceptional campaign art from all over the world. These examples are meant to inspire.   According to the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), annually around the world 1.3 billion tons of food is lost or wasted. In the world, where about one in nine people do not have enough food (that’s some 795 million people), food waste presents an enormous opportunity for tackling food insecurity. In order to bring more attention to the issue of fo…
  20. Study: Withdrawal from NAFTA would cost U.S. auto jobs - Companies
    01.18 / 15:35
    President-elect Donald Trump's vows to renegotiate the North American Free Trade Agreement and pursue more protectionist trade policies likely would have a negative effect on the U.S. auto industry, a new study…