Loss Aversion and Change

Loss Aversion and Change
  1. Loss Aversion and Change
    Blog: Confessions of a Community College DeanCould you live on 20 percent less income? What about 80 percent of your income? “Loss Aversion” is the term that the early developers of behavioral economics used to explain why when you ask people “could you live on 20 percent less income?,” most would say no, but if you asked them “could you live on 80 percent of your income?,” most would say yes. On the face of it, that looks like either…
    Education & Family

Could you live on 20 percent less income? What about 80 percent of your income?

“Loss Aversion” is the term that the early developers of behavioral economics used to explain why when you ask people “could you live on 20 percent less income?,” most would say no, but if you asked them “could you live on 80 percent of your income?,” most would say yes. On the face of it, that looks like either irrationality or innumeracy, since they’re just different ways of saying the same thing. But phrasing in a way that emphasizes loss gets a different answer than phrasing in a way that emphasizes what’s still there. It’s the same reason that someone who paid two dollars for a coffee mug will demand five to give it up.  

Behavioral economics is about looking for patterns in the ways that people act that run counter to what the model of a “rational economic actor” would suggest. It’s the effort to explain why “No Payments for 90 days!” works wonders, even though interest rates are vanishingly low and you still have to pay full price anyway.  

When I lived in Massachusetts, the sales tax was 6.25 percent. Once a year, usually in August, the state would declare a “tax-free weekend,” during which sales taxes were suspended on most things. (It didn’t apply to vehicles.) I remember a quote in the local paper from a store owner who marveled that if he had a “10% off” sale, nobody would show up, but 6.25% off brought people beating down the doors. “Tax free” made it sound like you were getting away with something, and “free” is a magic word. Mathematically, that’s silly; ten percent off is a better deal. But it worked.

The same idea holds in politics, in a different form. If you phrase a poll question about abortion around “convenience,” you get one response; if you phrase it around “the government,” you get a very different one, even if the policy implications of the two are identical.  

I’ve been thinking about loss aversion in the context of efforts to lead change on campus.  

If you start from the perspective that says “if we do what we always do, we’ll get the results we always get,” and you aren’t satisfied with those results, then the presumption in favor of trying something new is strong. But if you start from the perspective that says “this took a long time to develop, it’s mine, and the new thing could be worse,” then the burden of proof on the new thing is much higher. The second perspective more or less dismisses the dissatisfaction with the status quo and the prospect of improvement, instead focusing on the loss of what is currently there. It wants five dollars for the two dollar coffee mug.

Neither perspective is the whole truth, of course; seemingly good ideas can crash and burn, but the status quo is also a choice. Choosing to keep what you have is, in fact, choosing. It may not feel like it, but it is. If all changes were optional, I’d still have a full head of hair. Choosing to ignore the changing world is, in effect, choosing slow decline.

But moving people from “you’re taking my stuff!” to “let’s give it a try” isn’t easy, especially when they’re organized into groups -- departments, say -- in which people tend to echo and amplify each other’s fears. That’s especially true if there’s a…

Tags: #Colleges
  1. Fairmont Hotels will operate the revamped Century Plaza hotel

    Dailypilot.com - Education & Family
    01.20 / 03:30 dailypilot.com
    Luxury hotelier Fairmont Hotels & Resorts will operate the landmark Century Plaza hotel in Century City when it reopens in 2018 after a major makeover that includes the addition of two condominium towers. Fairmont will run the hotel and also serve the residents of the condo skyscrapers under co…
  2. Bloomington Environmental Commission discusses new initiatives

    Idsnews.com - Education
    01.20 / 03:08 idsnews.com
    Some initiatives included citizen-grown produce and apartment recycling…
  3. Lawyer of man charged with murdering SU student seeks dismissal of related tampering charge

    Dailyorange.com - Education
    01.20 / 03:03 dailyorange.com
    Cameron Isaac, one of the men charged with murdering Xiaopeng "Pippen" Yuan, had a pretrial hearing Thursday morning regarding a charge of tampering with a witness in the fourth degree. His lawyer is seeking to have the charge dismissed. Continue reading…
  4. Penn State student now faces vehicular homicide charges for his role in the death of Byron Markle

    Collegian.psu.edu - Education
    01.20 / 02:26 collegian.psu.edu
    Penn State student, Tyler Fasig, faces homicide charges for his involvement in the single-vehicle rollover on Sept. 9 that led to the death of fellow student Byron…
  5. Did I miss something in the conversation?

    Dailykos.com - Education & Family
    01.20 / 02:16 dailykos.com
    Here's another exchange an asshole trump supporter ‘friend’ and I had last week about the Secretary of Education nominee.  Did I misunderstand any part of the conversation?  Or is the asshole just ‘gaslighting’?  (not entirely sure of the definition of…
  6. Highlights of GS-Armstrong consolidation town hall meeting

    Thegeorgeanne.com - Education
    01.20 / 01:39 thegeorgeanne.com
    Georgia Southern University hosted a town hall meeting to discuss the details of the GS-ASU consolidation…
  7. Six Education Policy Areas Where Betsy DeVos' Views Still Aren't Clear - Politics K-12 - Education Week

    Blogs.edweek.org -  Immigrants
    01.20 / 01:38 blogs.edweek.org
    At her confirmation hearing for education secretary, DeVos gave general or somewhat limited answers to senators' questions on issues including ESSA accountability and early-childhood…
  8. On the Importance of Listening

    Insidehighered.com -Education
    01.20 / 01:34 www.insidehighered.com
    Blog: Student Affairs and TechnologyWe're moving to a new apartment in London. The reason is quite simple. Our current one bedroom flat isn't big enough for the Stoller Stroller Project. While Craigslist may be the go-to site for finding an apartment in the US, things are a bit different in the UK. There are certainly a lot of sites with rental listings, but most of them are connected to estate agencies. These agencies and their agents work with tenants to find rental…
  9. UVU Green Club and Students for Choice advocate change

    Uvureview.com - Education
    01.20 / 01:28 uvureview.com
    The political climate drives the Student for Choice Club and UVU Green Club to engage with the community. Both clubs were on display during Club Rush, a two-day event where UVU students set up a table to promote their clubs to the campus community Jan. 11-12. Students for Choice are sponsored through Planned Parenthood and…
  10. Billions in School Improvement Spending But Not Much Student Improvement - Inside School Research - Education Week

    Blogs.edweek.org -   Science
    01.20 / 01:27 blogs.edweek.org
    The Institute of Education Sciences released its final evaluation of the School Improvement Grants program, which Congress killed last…
  11. Soonerthon aims to raise $1 million for pediatric medical research this year

    Oudaily.com - Education
    01.20 / 01:26 oudaily.com
    The 21st annual Soonerthon campaign is setting its sights on a lofty goal this year, looking to raise $1 million to benefit hospitalized Oklahoma…
  12. UH Community College business student gains first hand experience in Japan

    Hawaii.edu - Education & Family
    01.20 / 00:54 hawaii.edu
    Kapiʻolani CC student, Kelsy Sonobe-Morita, will experience culture, language and education firsthand through Hawaiʻi CC’s study abroad…
  13. A Dispatch From the Outgoing U.S. Education Secretary - Education Week

    Blogs.edweek.org - Religion
    01.20 / 00:52 blogs.edweek.org
    In his final Commentary as education secretary, John B. King Jr. considers the state of American…
  14. Social-Emotional Development - Education Week

    Blogs.edweek.org -   Science
    01.20 / 00:51 blogs.edweek.org
    The amount of play that low-income students experience in their kindergarten classrooms predicts how engaged they are in school extracurricular activities in 8th grade, according to a study in the January issue of Applied Developmental…
  15. Author Interview: 'Visible Learning for Mathematics' - Classroom Q&A With Larry Ferlazzo - Education Week Teacher

    Blogs.edweek.org -   Science
    01.20 / 00:50 blogs.edweek.org
    Linda M. Gojak and Sara Delano Moore, two of the co-authors of "Visible Learning For Mathematics: What Works Best to Optimize Student Learning", agreed to answer a few questions about the…
  16. Miguel Ferrer, star of 'RoboCop,' 'NCIS: Los Angeles' and 'Twin Peaks,' dies at 61

    Dailypilot.com - Education & Family
    01.20 / 00:26 dailypilot.com
    Miguel Ferrer, an actor with a long list of credits ranging from “Twin Peaks” to his current role on CBS’ “NCIS: Los Angeles,” died of cancer on Thursday. He was 61. A fixture on TV and in movies since the 1980s, Ferrer’s reputation as a scene-stealer began with 1987’s “RoboCop,” where he played…
  17. NFL report: Julio Jones misses another practice but vows to play in Falcons' game against Packers

    Dailypilot.com - Education & Family
    01.20 / 00:26 dailypilot.com
    Atlanta Falcons All-Pro receiver Julio Jones missed his second day of practice Thursday because a sprained left toe. He said it's no big deal. Jones is confident he will be ready Sunday when Atlanta faces Green Bay in the NFC championship game.  In the fourth quarter of last week's win over S…
  18. At 'Nature Preschools,' Classes Are Outdoors - Education Week

    Blogs.edweek.org - Technology
    01.20 / 00:25 blogs.edweek.org
    Nature-based pre-primary programs are growing like weeds in forests and meadows around the…
  19. Teachers Are Among the Crowd Headed to Trump Inauguration, March - Teaching Now - Education Week Teacher

    Blogs.edweek.org -  Immigrants
    01.20 / 00:25 blogs.edweek.org
    Many teachers are taking their students to Washington to witness the inauguration of the 45th president, but some say the divisive nature of the election has made the experience a little different than in previous…
  20. Two Great Apps

    Bellaonline.com - Family
    01.20 / 00:24 bellaonline.com
    If you are reluctant to introduce toddlers to modern technology via an app on your phone or tablet, be assured that these two are superb! Find out more in this…