How a case against Israel officials helped Saudi Arabia


How a case against Israel officials helped Saudi Arabia
  1. How a case against Israel officials helped Saudi Arabia
    aljazeera.com
    'False alarm' war crime case was used by lobbyists to try and influence US politicians into revoking law Riyadh…
    Africa

A US lawyer with ties to Saudi Arabia filed a "false alarm" lawsuit against senior Israeli and Trump administration officials, which helped the country's lobbying efforts against legislation that allows US citizens to sue Riyadh over the September 11 attacks.

Al Jazeera has discovered that Martin McMahon, who filed the complaint in February at a district court, has connections to Saudi Arabia dating back to at least 2003.

The lawsuit alleges the Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, former foreign minister Tzipi Livni, the Trump administration's ambassador to Israel, David Friedman, and the Kushner Family Foundation, the charity of Trump's son-in-law and senior advisor Jared Kushner all committed or financed war crimes in violation of the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act (JASTA).

JASTA is an amendment to the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) that limited foreign states' immunity to lawsuits brought by US citizens in relation to support for "acts of terrorism". It became law in September 2016 after a veto from then-president Obama was overridden by US Congress.

The complaint against Israeli and Trump-related officials was then used by Saudi lobbyists to show members of Congress how a key ally could be put at risk by JASTA, according to Brian McGlinchey, editor of 28pages.org.

'Shaky lawsuit'

McGlinchey told Al Jazeera he became aware of the suit because it "was used as a talking point" for anti-JASTA lobbyists on Capitol Hill.

"They pointed to the complaint and said, 'Here are the unintended consequences,'" he said, explaining the lawsuit was used as an example of a US ally put at risk of legal action.

McGlinchey noted the February lawsuit appeared to have been made on weak grounds.

"When you looked at the actual complaint, the State of Israel isn't named," he said. "It seemed a shaky invocation of JASTA."

READ MORE: Saudi Arabia condemns passage of US 9/11 law

The amendment only applies to foreign states and related entities, not individuals, as in the lawsuit.

According to 28pages, a "false alarm" complaint refers to a lawsuit seemingly filed for the purpose of providing lobbyists another piece of ammunition to argue for their specific goal.

Others called into question the text of the suit itself, which is "long and rambling", according to William Dodge, a professor of law at the University of California's Davis School of Law and member of the US State Department's Advisory Committee on International Law. 

Just because you name JASTA in a complaint doesn't mean it will be seriously considered

William Dodge, University of California, Davis School of Law

"There's been a lot of litigation around foreign official immunity recently," Dodge said in an interview, naming several cases that are testing the limits of the immunity granted to officials such as a case brought against Muhammad Al Samantar, Somalia's prime minister from 1988 to 1990 under Somali strongman Siad Barre.

Samantar admitted to ordering extrajudicial torture and killings, the State Department decided he was not immune, though it wasn't an absolute ruling.

Still, "None of [the litigation] is around JASTA, because JASTA doesn't affect foreign officials. None of this depends on the passage of JASTA," Dodge explained. "Just because you name JASTA in a complaint doesn't mean it will be seriously considered."

Robert Tolchin, an attorney representing an accounting firm named in McMahon's lawsuit for working with the Kushner Family Foundation, which donates to Israeli settlement organisations in the occupied West Bank, is similarly confused by what he called the "legal mumbo jumbo" contained in the text.

According to a motion to dismiss filed by Tolchin, McMahon did not meet basic legal requirements of giving street addresses for the plaintiffs, using instead the city or country in which they live.

McMahon responded with an affidavit from Miko Peled, an anti-occupation Israeli activist and author living in the US, which said "locating an individual address in Palestine is a very difficult task" because of an "uncertain" postal system.

Tolchin filed another response saying many of the plaintiffs listed in the suit, including Peled, live in the US, so the reasoning remained without merit. His research also found 13 plaintiffs were killed by Israeli forces.

No representatives of the estates of the deceased have been named, Tolchin wrote, and the deceased "do not have standing to sue in their own name simply because a lawyer has decided to name them as plaintiffs".

Several of the living plaintiffs declined to be interviewed for this article, others did not respond to Al Jazeera's request for comment.

Al Jazeera asked Tolchin for his take on the legislation, to which he replied, "I'm not sure who's paying him to file these complaints, but I'm sure someone is."

Saudi connections

While it's not known who, if anyone, pays for the time required to file the complaints, Al Jazeera has learned that McMahon has a history of working for Saudi interests.

The attorney worked as a lobbyist for the Dallah al-Baraka Holding Company, a Saudi conglomerate, on the issues of banking, foreign relations, and law enforcement from March 2003 to August 2006, according to lobbying disclosures.

Al-Baraka is one of the largest business holdings in the Middle East with investments in banking, healthcare, manufacturing and many other sectors. It has also been accused of providing funds to the 19 al-Qaeda hijackers responsible for the September 11, 2001 attacks in a complaint filed in 2003.

The suit alleges that al-Baraka bank provided Osama bin Laden, a Saudi national and one of the founders of al-Qaeda who is accused of planning of the attacks, with "financial infrastructures in Sudan beginning in 1983" and continuing for decades.

It also claims that Omar al-Bayoumi, a Saudi national who allegedly befriended two of the hijackers and provided them with monetary support after they entered the US, was assistant to the Director of Finance for Dallah Avco, an aviation holding of al-Baraka, according to an application for a PhD programme.

Another lawsuit filed against al-Baraka alleges the conglomerate gave donations to al-Haramain Foundation, a Saudi charity, that funnelled financial support to al-Qaeda, even after the events of September 11, according to a CBS News report from 2004. The US Treasury found direct ties between al-Haramain and al-Qaeda that year. 

These and many other, similar suits were merged by August 1, when Saudi Arabia's attorneys filed a motion to dismiss legal action against the kingdom. McMahon currently serves as the defence attorney for Wael Jalaidan, one of the original founders of al-Qaeda, in one of these cases.

Jalaidan, a Saudi national, was named "an associate of …

  1. Gamescom enters new political territory

    Dw.com - Business
    08.21 / 11:14 dw.com
    Gamers are voters, too. At least the ones over 18. Now shortly before a general election, top policymakers in Germany have discovered the digital gaming community and are sitting up and taking…
  2. Proudly South African: Christopher Ndaba cycled 72 km for a Cape Town boy with cancer he’d never met

    Thesouthafrican.com - Africa
    08.21 / 11:05 thesouthafrican.com
    There's it. Right in the feels. The post Proudly South African: Christopher Ndaba cycled 72 km for a Cape Town boy with cancer he’d never met appeared first on The South…
  3. Traffic officer arrested after taking a bribe of just R40

    Thesouthafrican.com - Africa
    08.21 / 11:05 thesouthafrican.com
    We all know there is corruption flowing through far too many sectors of our country. We know bribes happen but we didn’t really know that someone would actually accept a R40 bribe. Well, this traffic officer has just been arrested for doing exactly that. The 55-year-old traffic officer in Johannesburg has was arrested after allegedly taking The post Traffic officer arrested after taking a bribe of just R40 appeared first on The South Af…
  4. Adult ice lollies: Get your gin fix with these new gin and tonic popsicles

    Thesouthafrican.com - Africa
    08.21 / 11:05 thesouthafrican.com
    An ice-lolly for grown-ups! Make the best out of this coming summer with a classic Gin and Tonic in the form of a popsicle. The post Adult ice lollies: Get your gin fix with these new gin and tonic popsicles appeared first on The South…
  5. White farmers launch fresh international legal action against Zimbabwe

    Thesouthafrican.com - Africa
    08.21 / 11:05 thesouthafrican.com
    Could a little-known legislation from 2008 give these Zim farmers the compensation they deserve? The post White farmers launch fresh international legal action against Zimbabwe appeared first on The South…
  6. China's Great Wall hopes to buy parts of Fiat Chrysler

    Dw.com - Business
    08.21 / 10:12 dw.com
    China's Great Wall Motor Corporation has voiced interest in bidding for Fiat Chrysler. The Italian-American carmaker has been grappling with rising costs and seeks to develop technology for self-driving…
  7. Nigeria: Gunmen Kills Governor's Aide

    Allafrica.com - Africa
    08.21 / 10:03 allafrica.com
    [Daily Trust] Makurdi -Gunmen suspected to be hired assassins yesterday shot and killed Governor Samuel Ortom's Principal Special Assistant on Knowledge Economy and Investments, Dr Tavershima Adyorough, at his residence in…
  8. Ethiopia: Progress With Meles' Legacy Five Years Since His Departure

    Allafrica.com - Africa
    08.21 / 10:03 allafrica.com
    [Ethiopian Herald] 17 years of armed struggle and 21 years of political leadership make up a significant portion of the late former Prime Minister Meles Zenawi's 57 years of stay on earth. The biography of Meles shows that he left his higher studies at the Medical school of Addis Ababa University to join fierce armed struggle in northern…
  9. South Africa: Will Grace Mugabe Ever Return to South Africa?

    Allafrica.com - Africa
    08.21 / 10:03 allafrica.com
    [allAfrica] Cape Town -The scene has been set for a protracted legal battle between the South African Government and Gabriella Engels, the alleged victim of an assault by Zimbabwean First Lady Grace…
  10. Nigeria: 'Nigeria's Unity Is Settled and Not Negotiable' - Buhari

    Allafrica.com - Africa
    08.21 / 10:03 allafrica.com
    [Premium Times] President Muhammadu Buhari has said the federal government would not tolerate separatist movements and inflammatory statements that threaten Nigeria unity and…
  11. Kenya: County to Sue Police Over Baby Pendo's Death

    Allafrica.com - Africa
    08.21 / 10:03 allafrica.com
    [Nation] The Kisumu County government will sue the National Police Service over the death of a six-month old…
  12. UNAMA: ISIL, Taliban jointly attacked Mirzawalang

    Aljazeera.com - Africa
    08.21 / 10:03 aljazeera.com
    At least 36 were killed in early August violence by fighters of both groups, UNAMA says, as witnesses recall…
  13. Jacinda Ardern embroiled in another sexism row

    Aljazeera.com - Africa
    08.21 / 10:03 aljazeera.com
    Minority party leader offends popular female candidate of Labour Party as other hopefuls quit election…
  14. Absa Premiership: PSL fixtures for 22 and 23 August 2017

    Thesouthafrican.com - Africa
    08.21 / 10:03 thesouthafrican.com
    The midweek PSL fixtures make for some tasty viewing, especially after the opening weekend of the Absa Premiership sprung a few surprises. The post Absa Premiership: PSL fixtures for 22 and 23 August 2017 appeared first on The South…
  15. Cape Town water crisis: Biggest consumers will have their supply throttled… at a price

    Thesouthafrican.com - Africa
    08.21 / 09:03 thesouthafrican.com
    No more baths. The post Cape Town water crisis: Biggest consumers will have their supply throttled… at a price appeared first on The South…
  16. Jacob Zuma foundation goes broke, ditches students it promised bursaries to

    Thesouthafrican.com - Africa
    08.21 / 09:03 thesouthafrican.com
    Jacob Zuma seems to be running out of quite a few things lately, the country’s trust, (lost that ages ago) ANC MPs and now even money for his foundation. The Sunday Times reports that the Jacob G Zuma Foundation admitted that it has run out of money and cannot pay university fees for at least The post Jacob Zuma foundation goes broke, ditches students it promised bursaries to appeared first on The South A…
  17. Grace Mugabe isn’t off the hook yet: AfriForum will challenge her immunity

    Thesouthafrican.com - Africa
    08.21 / 09:03 thesouthafrican.com
    Can Nel's team snatch justice from the jaws of corruption? The post Grace Mugabe isn’t off the hook yet: AfriForum will challenge her immunity appeared first on The South…
  18. India's Bihar state reels under unprecedented flooding

    Aljazeera.com - Africa
    08.21 / 09:03 aljazeera.com
    Death toll rises above 250 as eastern Indian state faces its worst flooding in decades, affecting 13 million…
  19. German air passenger tax under increased fire

    Dw.com - Business
    08.21 / 08:19 dw.com
    In response to German carrier Air Berlin filing for bankruptcy, German Economy Minister Brigitte Zypries has demanded that the country's air passenger duty be scrapped as soon as possible. Here's…
  20. Sir Ken Robinson's education revolution

    Aljazeera.com - Africa
    08.21 / 08:10 aljazeera.com
    Education expert Sir Ken Robinson argues that we should radically rethink how we educate our…