Chomsky still believes in the old Israel. I did too, once upon a time


Chomsky still believes in the old Israel. I did too, once upon a time
  1. Chomsky still believes in the old Israel. I did too, once upon a time
    mondoweiss.net
    If you know what Israel's plan for Gaza is, you must give up on erudite chit-chats with even the finest Israelis. But Noam Chomsky is still caught up in a romance of what Israel could have been, so he opposes the only thing that can change it,…
    Middle Easte

On Aug. 8, we published a piece about Noam Chomsky’s objections to the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) campaign targeting Israel. The writer, a frequent contributor, posted this as a comment on the piece but agree to expand it for a post. –Ed.

My issue with Chomsky’s position is what it always was: he operates from a prism that is strongly colored by the Israel that was once upon a time, perhaps 50-60 years ago. Chomsky was around then to hear and witness the many idealistic statements of the then Israeli intellectuals and political leaders. And if he was impressed by the would-be forging of a come-from-behind wandering, wondering and sometimes-much-persecuted people into a socialist just society, why, it would be hard to blame him. Thus was Israel presented to the world and to itself. I believed it too, once upon a time.

I don’t want to open a debate on whether that “old” Israel, that ephemeral citadel on a hill, that light unto the nations, was ever real or not (well, we know there’s no great light without much darkness….right?). Fact is, it was real enough in the minds of many, both inside Israel and outside it. Especially educated Jewish people, who must have felt a certain kinship with the nascent little country that could beget great thinkers, writers and humanitarian visionaries in such short order. Chomsky is old enough to have at least some of his opinions and judgments imprinted by those once-upon-a-time impressions.

Unfortunately, while he clearly processed that Israel has changed greatly, and not for the better, he still tends to lay the blame on the “occupation” (in parenthesis, because it’s really an occupation of the mind that took place, right along with the physical one). In that he finds confirmation among many of his fellow intellectuals, including the fine left-leaning ones in Israel, who passionately mourn the Israel that was and could have been and has now turned stray. Their very existence continues to give Chomsky hope about fine things like “International Law” and “Human Rights” and “Justice”. Sometimes, as much as I hate to say it, he sounds almost child-like, hanging on to these civilized concepts, as if they were life rafts (perhaps they are. Not for me to say).

Chomsky is probably too old now to change his own paradigm, just as many, including the founders of Gush Shalom, are. Yet, there has been a major paradigm change – a catastrophic one, really. The Israel that is is not the one that was, and definitely not the one that was imagined. The Israel that is is a different beast altogether. One could say, it’s almost a monster, a not altogether sane incarnation begotten to impress with great new might but now unleashing mostly fright and terror in its wake, as it flails, ever so powerful but still feeling frail and persecuted. There is no talking to most Israelis these days about fine concepts like “international law”, “justice” and “rights”, as those be taken as fighting words. There is no convincing them that one needs to give a little to get a lot, because all they care about is how to make the “little” into minuscule, vanishingly so. This Israel has little use for some elusive human “rights”, unless they are Jewish-Israeli rights, and not just any Jews, but the “right kind” of Jews.

To my mind, and based on what I read of him, Chomsky processes much that is true and deep, yet little does he process just how depraved Israeli society has become in moral terms. Probably because the people he knows do not appear depraved in the slightest. Little does Chomsky know what collective insanity really looks like because he does not come face to face with its frightful daily manifestations. Little does Chomsky know – except in the deepest recesses of his mind – what the Gaza ghetto is really all about, because to know what the plan for Gaza is, is to give up on erudite chit-chats with even the finest Israelis. Who know, of course, what Gaza is, and what it is to be, but manage to put it out of their well-tuned minds.

I like Chomsky a lot for his clear-eyed views on many issues that are important to anyone considering themselves a progressive. But I find it difficult to deal with his refusal to look reality in the face on a whole host of matters; from BDS to Human Rights to the Rule of Law, be it in Israel or the US. While he rails ever so eloquently against the encroaching corporate state, he still speaks as if half-measures and fine talk will have any effect on its rapacious ascent. And while he rails – ever so capably – against the ravages of neoliberalism, surely he can see for himself how well we have all been doing battling that particular beast. More like batting our eyelashes and clutching our pearls, while losing every skirmish, I’d say.

I don’t hold it against him that he holds out hope for the best in human nature to prevail. I don’t expect him to sink into intellectual despondency seeing the enormity of humanity’s challenges. But even as I take great comfort in hearing him speak, so lucidly, so humanely on matters of great import, I find myself wishing he could reach for more effective tools that go just a bit beyond the usual arsenal of laws and rights. After all, law can be bent into lawfare and rights can be twisted into boomerangs. But Chomsky alas, is not one to whistle for the dragons, and in all fairness, perhaps it’s not his task.

Likewise, because of his rose-colored g…

  1. Erdogan: Turkey and Iran discussing joint action against Kurds

    Middleeasteye.net - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 11:05 middleeasteye.net
    Language Undefined Turkish president says joint action against the PKK and its Iranian affiliate PJAK was 'always on the…
  2. Tragedy: Three People Die and Priceless Renaissance Books Burn in Fire

    Albawaba.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 10:03 albawaba.com
    Three people were killed and priceless original manuscripts from the Renaissance era were destroyed after a fire broke in a historical building in the southern Italian city of Cosenza, reported the German news agency (dpa). The victims have yet to be identified, but they are presumed to be two men and a woman who had squatted in the third-floor flat of a building in the center of the city, reported Italy’s ANSA news agency. The fire broke out Friday afternoon on the floor where the w…
  3. Saudi Arabia Says Public Sector Contractors Exempt From Workers’ Tax

    Albawaba.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 10:03 albawaba.com
    The Council of Ministers has announced that contractors working on public sector projects before the decision to impose workers’ tax are exempt from paying the levy. © Copyright 2017 The Saudi Gazette. All Rights Reserved. read mo…
  4. Russia kills over 200 ISIS militants in Syria convoy bombing, defense ministry reports

    Haaretz.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 10:03 haaretz.com
    Russian warplanes attacked an ISIS convoy on route to Syrian city of Deir…
  5. The occupation at 50: No end in sight for Palestinians

    Al-monitor.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 09:38 al-monitor.com
    The Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories will not end until world powers convince Israel that their is an economic and political price to pay for sustaining…
  6. ‘Deconfliction Line’ in Syria ia Given the Go Ahead Amidst Fight Against IS

    Albawaba.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 09:03 albawaba.com
    The U.S.-led coalition, its principal Syrian ally, Russia and the Syrian regime have agreed to a geographical "deconfliction line" or buffer zone in northeastern Syria meant to prevent clashes and focus military efforts on Daesh, the Pentagon confirmed Sunday. Spokesman Eric Pahon told Anadolu Agency the line "runs in an irregular arc" from a point southwest of Tabqa along the Euphrates River toward Deir ez-Zour. It does not touch the city itself, however.  …
  7. The Hitman's Bodyguard Protects its Client to the Top of the Box Office

    Albawaba.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 09:03 albawaba.com
    The Samuel L. Jackson-Ryan Reynolds action comedy The Hitman's Bodyguard is the No. 1 movie in North America this weekend, earning $21.6 million in receipts, BoxOfficeMojo.com announced Sunday. Coming in at No. 2 is Annabelle: Creation at No. 2 with $15.5 million, followed by Logan Lucky at No. 3 with $8 million, Dunkirk at No. 4 with $6.7 million and The Nut Job 2: Nutty by Nature at No. 5 with $5.1 million. …
  8. Shell Loads First Load of Cargo Containing Oil From Libya in 5 Years

    Albawaba.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 08:10 albawaba.com
    Royal Dutch Shell loaded 600,000 barrels of crude oil from the Libyan port of Zueitina on Saturday, industry sources said, its first cargo from the war-torn country in over five years.In June analysts reported a peak in oil output in Libya with around a million barrels a day (BPD) produced in the country, a four-year high. Copyright @ 2017 The New Arab. …
  9. Jordan’s King Abdullah Reaffirms Support for Unified Libya

    Albawaba.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 08:10 albawaba.com
    His Majesty King Abdullah on Sunday received at Basman Palace Libyan lower house speaker, Aqila Saleh, who is currently visiting the Kingdom, according to a Royal Court statement. The meeting discussed developments in the Libyan arena and the efforts exerted in the war on terror. © Copyright The Jordan Times. All rights reserved. read …
  10. Qatar denies blocking Saudi hajj pilgrimage flights

    Middleeasteye.net - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 08:09 middleeasteye.net
    Language Undefined Qatar says Saudi claims that it has refused to allow Saudi Airlines flights to land in Qatar are…
  11. Saudi gamble on Hamas could pay off, or enrich rival Iran

    Al-monitor.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 07:50 al-monitor.com
    The Saudis are increasing pressure on Hamas, which might win them points with US President Donald Trump and Israel, but drive the Palestinian movement and its allies toward…
  12. #ArabArtists Take Twitter to Showcase Their Beautiful Work

    Albawaba.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 07:16 albawaba.com
    Most perception of the Middle East and the Arab world in general comes from Western media. It's difficult, for a variety of political and social reasons, for Arab artists to tell their own stories. But sometimes artists do emerge—buried under misconception, their work rises like flowers from cement. These Arab artists used the #ArabArtists hashtag on Twitter to showcase their art, and we thought we'd show-off some of it. …
  13. The Matrix, Lethal Weapon Producer Joel Silver Sued Over Wrongful Death

    Albawaba.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 06:12 albawaba.com
    Famed Hollywood producer Joel Silver has been sued for the 2015 drowning death of his assistant during a star-studded party at an exclusive resort in Bora Bora. Copyright © UPI, 2017. All Rights Reserved. read …
  14. Iraqi Kurds may postpone referendum in return for concessions

    Middle-east-online.com - Middl Easte
    08.21 / 02:06 middle-east-online.com
    Kurdish Regional Government may consider putting off upcoming independence referendum if Baghdad is ready to help overcome financial crisis, settle disputed…
  15. Syria’s transition scenarios for future rounds of talks

    Middle-east-online.com - Middl Easte
    08.21 / 02:06 middle-east-online.com
    An objective of the Riyadh conference is to purge the Syrian opposition of any Qatar-backed…
  16. In Egypt, Syrian refugees recreate Syria

    Middle-east-online.com - Middl Easte
    08.21 / 02:06 middle-east-online.com
    Estimates put the amount that Syrians invested in Egypt since the Syrian civil war started at nearly $500…
  17. In African tour, Sisi seeks to rebuild ties, address security and water concerns

    Middle-east-online.com - Middl Easte
    08.21 / 02:06 middle-east-online.com
    'During times of need, Egypt found few backers in the continent,' Gamal Bayoumi, a former assistant foreign…
  18. Assad says no Syria ties for countries backing rebels

    Middle-east-online.com - Middl Easte
    08.21 / 02:06 middle-east-online.com
    Reports suggest that Western countries could seek to quietly resume ties with Assad regime but president warns that any support for rebels must…
  19. Iraq Kurds might delay independence vote for Baghdad concessions: Official

    Middleeasteye.net - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 01:07 middleeasteye.net
    Language Undefined Kurdish delegation visits Baghdad to sound out Iraqi leaders on proposals that might convince Kurds to delay…
  20. Israel threatens to demolish Bedouin homes despite High Court order

    Haaretz.com - Middle Easte
    08.21 / 00:06 haaretz.com
    In legal spat, Civil Administration says Bedouin groups are playing for time and not addressing the issue in disputed E1 area near Ma’aleh A…