Keep the Iran nuclear deal


Keep the Iran nuclear deal
  1. Keep the Iran nuclear deal
    njjewishnews.com
    When he proclaimed at the 2016 AIPAC policy conference that “my number-one priority is to dismantle the disastrous deal with Iran,” then-presidential candidate Donald Trump was greeted with sustained cheering and applause. Now that Trump is president and able to fulfill his promise, does the organized American-Jewish community want him to do so? I believe the answer — with some exceptions — is no. »Read More Published in: Op-Eds…
    New Jersey (NJ)

by Martin J. RaffelSpecial to NJJN

September 13, 2017

When he proclaimed at the 2016 AIPAC policy conference that “my number-one priority is to dismantle the disastrous deal with Iran,” then-presidential candidate Donald Trump was greeted with sustained cheering and applause. Now that Trump is president and able to fulfill his promise, does the organized American-Jewish community want him to do so? I believe the answer — with some exceptions — is no. 

In July 2015, Iran and the P5+1 (the five permanent members of the UN Security Council plus Germany) signed the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) in which Iran agreed to eliminate or substantially reduce its stockpiles of medium and low-enriched uranium; to reduce the number of its gas centrifuges; to refrain from building heavy-water facilities; and to permit the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) regular and virtually unfettered access to all known Iranian nuclear facilities. The IAEA, under the terms of the deal, could also gain access to suspected sites, including military installations, if there were grounds for doing so. Essentially, the deal put Iran’s path to nuclear weapons on hold for at least a decade. 

It did not grant Iran, a signatory to the Nuclear Nonproliferation Pact (NPT), the right to produce nuclear weapons after that period. Nor did it require Iran to cease other aspects of its misbehavior, such as supporting global terrorism, violating human rights, and developing missiles capable of delivering weapons of mass destruction. In return for its compliance, all nuclear-related sanctions against Iran imposed by the U.S. and the international community were to be suspended. 

At the risk of reopening old wounds, let’s recall the situation prior to the signing of the Iran nuclear deal. Against the wishes of President Barack Obama, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made an unprecedented appearance before a joint session of Congress urging the assembled senators and representatives to reject the deal that Obama had worked so hard to achieve. AIPAC, the American Jewish Committee (AJC), the ADL, and major Orthodox organizations such as the Orthodox Union and Agudath Israel advocated for the same. 

Recognizing the deep divisions within our Jewish community, the central umbrella bodies — Conference of Presidents, The Jewish Federations of North America, and the Jewish Council for Public Affairs (JCPA) — took no position. Some individual federations, including Greater MetroWest, voiced their disapproval, although most, like the Jewish Federation in the Heart of New Jersey, remained neutral, instead choosing to offer educational programs to enhance their communities’ understanding of the issues. The Reform and Conservative movements did not take sides, and at the time polls showed that most American Jews supported the deal. 

There was some ugliness to the debate. In some quarters, supporters of the deal were labelled as appeasers and opponents were accused of being warmongers. 

Full disclosure — at times I wavered, having seen merit to both sides. In the end, and purely on a personal basis (I had already retired from the JCPA), I expressed support for the deal. That said, I’m no pacifist; I had also hoped to see a congressional resolution authorizing the president to use “all means necessary” to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon if there was compelling evidence that it was on the verge of doing so.

Opponents of the deal did not muster enough votes in Congress to block it, and the U.S. signed on. However, Congress did adopt the Iran Nuclear Agreement Review Act of 2015 (also known as the Corker-Cardin law), which requires the president to certify Iranian compliance every 90 days. Should he fail to do so, Congress must decide, within 60 days, whether to reimpose the sanctions. Trump, based on the advice of his foreign policy and security advisors, has already certified Iranian compliance twice, in May and again in July, although very reluctantly. Meanwhile, at the end of August, IAEA Director General Yukiya Amano of Japan announced, for the eighth time since the deal was struck, that Iran remains in basic compliance, findings that have been accepted by the other P5+1 partners. 

However, indications are that next month, the next time the deal comes up for presidential review, Trump will ignore the IAEA and decertify Iranian compliance. On Sept. 5, U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley told an audience at the American Enterprise Institute, “I’m not making the case for decertifying; I’m just saying if he [the president] should decertify, he has the grounds.” She also argued that even if Iran is living up to the requirements of the nuclear deal, the president can and should take other considerations into account when determining whether to decertify, including missile development, support for terrorism, and overall U.S. national security interests. Haley noted that there are other matters to consider besides compliance with the JCPOA. “This is a jigsaw puzzle,” she said. 

As we approach the October decision point — with the prospect that a congressional debate on reimposing sanctions may follow the president’s possible decertification — where does the organized Jewish community stand? Are we as divided as we were in 2015 before the deal was signed; or, as I believe, has a consensus now crystallized that if Iran is indeed complying with the terms of the agreement, the U.S. should preserve the deal?  

AIPAC, AJC, and ADL, early opponents of the deal, have not urged the president to decertify, at least not yet. To my knowledge, no Jewish federation anywhere in the country has yet to weigh in. Significantly, Netanyahu, perhaps the strongest critic of the deal anywhere in the world, has not voiced an opinion. He and other Israeli leaders seem much more concerned these days about growing Iranian influence in Syria and Lebanon, especially the strengthening of Hezbollah’s rocket capabilities. Sen. Cory Booker (D-N.J.), who voted in favor of…

  1. Hamilton elementary school teacher arrested for shoplifting

    Trentonian.com-NJ
    09.22 / 00:46 www.trentonian.com
    HAMILTON >> A township elementary school teacher was taught a lesson in stealing.Marisa Naro, 29, of the first block of Erica Lynne Way, was arrested Sept. 10 for shoplifting at the ShopRite on Route 33 in Hamilton Township, officials said Thursday. Naro is a special education teacher at Langtree Elementary School, according to information posted on the Hamilton Township School District's…
  2. Records show NJ Transit didn't screen Hoboken engineer for sleep apnea before crash

    Mycentraljersey.com - Somerville
    09.22 / 00:13 mycentraljersey.com
    The NJ Transit engineer involved in last September's fatal train crash was not evaluated for obstructive sleep …
  3. Cause of Death Determined for Missing Hiker

    Mercerme.com - Mercer County
    09.22 / 00:03 mercerme.com
    As reported by MercerMe, the body of Hopewell resident Alex Stevens, was found on September 18th, sixteen days after starting a three-day hike in New York’s High Peaks Wilderness Area on Wallface Mountain. A massive search ensued after family reported him missing on September 10th when he failed to meet friends in New York City. […
  4. Explorations offers daytime learning experiences for seniors

    Mercerme.com - Mercer County
    09.22 / 00:03 mercerme.com
    Explorations, now in its tenth year, has lined up five exciting courses for senior residents of Hopewell Valley and neighboring communities. Classes will begin Monday, October 9.  Registration closes October 5. The following four courses will be held at the Pennington Presbyterian Church and begin at 1pm: “Philosophy of Existentialism, How I Learned to Love [&…
  5. Retired Parsippany police captain said there was 'a vendetta' against him

    Dailyrecord.com - Morristown
    09.21 / 23:58 dailyrecord.com
    Retired Parsippany police captain said he lost overtime, suffered stress and disparate treatment due to retaliation over his reports of…
  6. Atlantic City Boys and Girls club reopens Chelsea location

    Pressofatlanticcity.com-NJ
    ATLANTIC CITY — For some residents and volunteers, Thursday was a day they could return home to a site that closed in 2…
  7. Trenton Police: We found drugs, BB gun and 'toy gun' at Franklin Elementary

    Trentonian.com-NJ
    09.21 / 23:48 www.trentonian.com
    TRENTON >> The Franklin Elementary police investigation that began Wednesday afternoon has exposed widespread troubles at the Trenton public school involving drugs and weapons.A Franklin student brought a toy gun to the school on Monday, another student brought marijuana to school on Tuesday and another student brought a BB gun to the school on Wednesday, police said on…
  8. Ethics Case Against Mazie Slater Lawyers, Brought by Ex-Partner, Dismissed

    Njlawjournal.com - New Jersey (NJ)
    09.21 / 23:22 njlawjournal.com
    An ethics case stemming from the long-running feud between onetime law firm colleagues, lodged two years ago against two name partners from Mazie Slater Katz & Freeman, has reached its…
  9. Camden man fatally shot in Whitman Park

    Courierpostonline.com - Local
    Khareem Roberts, 33, was 19th person to die violently in Camden this …
  10. Norcross meets with DACA students

    Courierpostonline.com - Local
    Sen. Donald Norcross and Rutgers-Camden chancellor speak in defense of dreamers as group's fate hangs in the…
  11. NJ Football: Freehold forfeits game due to ineligible player

    App.com - New Jersey (NJ)
    09.21 / 22:20 app.com
    Freehold must forfeit its season-opening win over Freehold Township for using an ineligible player in its first two…
  12. Ethics Case Against Mazie Slater Lawyers, Brought by Ex-Partner, Won't Proceed

    Njlawjournal.com - New Jersey (NJ)
    09.21 / 22:17 njlawjournal.com
    An ethics case stemming from the long-running feud between onetime law firm colleagues, lodged two years ago against two name partners from Mazie Slater Katz & Freeman, has reached its…
  13. Trenton dad finds man in 6-year-old daughter's bed, police say

    Nj1015.com - New Jersey (NJ)
    09.21 / 22:17 nj1015.com
    The man, who is wanted by immigration police, jumped from the bedroom on the second floor and was caught by police. Continue…
  14. Amtrak plans more track closures this winter, report says

    Nj1015.com - New Jersey (NJ)
    09.21 / 22:17 nj1015.com
    Amtrak may be planning more track closures at New York Penn Station starting in February that would completely replace tracks. Continue…
  15. Teen and elderly man go missing in same Central Jersey town

    Nj1015.com - New Jersey (NJ)
    09.21 / 22:17 nj1015.com
    Two separate searches are underway in Mercer County for a college-age man and an elderly man with dementia. Continue…
  16. NJ Transit didn't screen Hoboken engineer for sleep apnea at exam two months before crash

    Mycentraljersey.com - Somerville
    09.21 / 22:09 mycentraljersey.com
    The NJ Transit engineer involved in last September's fatal train crash was not evaluated for obstructive sleep …
  17. Perth Amboy seeks joint effort to rebuild Puerto Rico

    Mycentraljersey.com - Somerville
    09.21 / 22:09 mycentraljersey.com
    Mayor Wilda Diaz will be working with other Latino state leaders to help rebuild Puerto Rico following the devastation of Hurricane…
  18. The Rotary Means Business Fellowship

    Paramuspost.com - New Jersey (NJ)
    09.21 / 22:00 paramuspost.com
    Provides Rotarians business networking events to meet and socialize with other Rotarians in business. The first Rotary Club was formed when attorney Paul P. Harris called together a meeting of three business acquaintances in downtown Chicago, United States, at Harris's friend Gustave Loehr's office in the Unity Building on Dearborn Street on February 23, 1…
  19. BAHAMA BREEZE CELEBRATES ALL THINGS RUM WITH 5TH ANNUAL RUMTOBERFEST

    Paramuspost.com - New Jersey (NJ)
    09.21 / 22:00 paramuspost.com
    Enjoy Brand-new Rum Cocktails, Live Music and More Bahama Breeze is kicking-off its fifth annual Rumtoberfest, an event dedicated to combining rum and fun, now through November 5. This year’s Rumtoberfest introduces the restaurant’s largest rum flight, the Rum Raid – featuring eight rum-based cocktails for parties of two or more to conqu…
  20. Jets' Mo Wilkerson sacks groceries for ShopRite charity in Hanover

    Dailyrecord.com - Morristown
    09.21 / 21:53 dailyrecord.com
    Jets star Mo Wilkerson bags groceries at ShopRite of Morristown in Hanover for ShopRite Partners in…