Analysts Are Quitting the State Department’s Anti-Propaganda Team

Analysts Are Quitting the State Department’s Anti-Propaganda Team
  1. Analysts Are Quitting the State Department’s Anti-Propaganda Team
    The Global Engagement Center is struggling to keep up with its missions: countering ISIS recruitment and Russian…

The chief technology officer at the U.S. State Department’s anti-propaganda center left last week, along with two other members of its analytics team, Defense One has learned. The departures raise new questions about the Global Engagement Center, the two-year-old office that remains leaderless nine months into the Trump administration.

The State Department would not say how many data analysts remain at the Center, but one former senior official described the three team members as “the whole enchilada” and added “things are bad.”

The Center’s CTO Nash Borges departed on Friday, leaving behind a goodbye email. “Today is my last day and in sticking with recent [science and technology] efforts to share important ideas to keep the GEC marching forward to accomplish its important mission, I thought that I would begin with a review of bureaucratic politics theory,” Borges wrote. (Defense One obtained a copy of the email.) “What follow are excerpts from A Glossary of Political Economy Terms by Dr. Paul M. Johnson of Auburn University. Any familiarities that you observe are purely coincidental ;).”

In his email, Borges does not explicitly say why he quit. (Nor did he respond to requests for comments on the record.) But he cheekily quotes Johnson’s writing on bureaucracy and “bureaucratic politics” at considerable length, and suggests that GEC managers read a book subtitled “What the world’s greatest managers do differently.”

One former State employee said Borges was burnt out by a commute of more than two hours from his home in Maryland.

Two other members of the analytics team quit at “around the same time” and departed on Friday, the former employee said. Neither analyst responded to requests for comment by press time.

The Obama administration established the GEC in 2016 to counter ISIS’ various online messaging efforts, directing the new office to use data and to work with international partners in a bid to undermine extremist propaganda more effectively than State’s previous such unit, the Center for Strategic Counterterrorism Communications. GEC’s toolbox included various outreach efforts, including highly targeted ad buys on Facebook.

Last year, the 2017 National Defense Authorization Act gave the GEC an additional mission: fighting “foreign propaganda and disinformation directed against United States national security interests and proactively advance fact-based narratives that support United States allies and interests.” The Act, which became law in December, allowed the Global Engagement Center to ask the Pentagon for $40 million, bringing its total 2017 spending to about $80 million. About $60 million of that was to be used to counter Russian influence operations; about $19 million was aimed at ISIS.

The change of administrations left the GEC leaderless. A telephone directory dated Sept. 11, 2017, indicates that neither the director’s job, which requires Senate confirmation, nor the acting director’s job, which does not, have been filled. Defense One obtained a copy of the directory.

In August, Politico reported that Secretary of State Rex Tillerson was “spurning” the $80 million in funding, much to the chagrin of lawmakers. (GEC representatives said they were in the process of asking the Pentagon for the $40 million specified in the 2017 NDAA.)

“Congress has provided substantial resources to combat foreign propaganda, particularly from Russia. There is broad agreement that the U.S. Government is behind the curve on this threat,” said Sen. Rob, Portman, R-Ohio, said in a statement. “Countering foreign propaganda should be a top priority, and it is very concerning that progress on combatting this problem is being delayed because the State Department isn’t tapping into these resources.”

Tillerson relented at the end of August, agreeing that the State Department would complete its Pentagon request and put the funds to work.

Kremlin vs. US Facebook Buys

Last week, the GEC’s anti-propaganda mission rose to national attention again when it was revealed that the Kremlin had purchased Facebook ads worth $100,000 in the runup to the 2016 election. The ads “appeared to focus on amplifying divisive social and political messages across the ideological spectrum — touching on topics from LGBT matters to race issues to immigration to gun rights,” Facebook chief security officer Alex Stamos  wrote in a blog post.

Analysts are still trying to figure out the reach and impact of the Kremlin’s ad buy effort. But with the right user data, $100,000 buys a lot of influence on Facebook. At the Defense One Summit last November, former GEC director Michael Lumpkin described how the Center was using the data it received as a Facebook advertiser to maximize the effectiveness of its own targeted appeals.

“Using Facebook ads, I can go within Facebook, I can go grab an audience, I can pick Country X, I need age group 13 to 34, I need people who have liked — whether it’s Abu Bakr Al Baghdadi or any other set — I can shoot and hit them directly with messaging,” Lumpkin said. He emphasized that with the right data, effective message targeting could be done for “pennies a click.”

Facebook can’t sell personally identifiable information directly to advertisers. But ad buyers can use the vast amount of data Facebook collects on its users to target their ads extremely precisely. In the FCC…

  1. Republicans are pushing for a $1.5 Trilllon Tax cut over 10 years…. - Politics
    09.22 / 03:21
    This all comes after months of methodical negotiations meant to avoid a repeat of the GOP’s disjointed and thus-far unsuccessful efforts to repeal the Affordable Care A…
  2. Carney signs bills simplifying licensing for teachers - Politics
    09.22 / 03:14
    DOVER — Gov. John Carney signed Thursday two bills that simplify the licensure requirements for educators, with the stated goal of allowing the state to attract and retain more teachers and other school personnel. House Substitute 1 for House Bill 143 eliminates the general knowledge exam for teachers, gives new educators coming from out of […
  3. Overnight Defense: Trump announces new North Korea sanctions | Former officials urge Trump to exit Iran deal | Trump tou - Politics
    09.22 / 03:11
    THE TOPLINE: President Trump on Thursday signed an executive order imposing new sanctions on North Korea as the U.S. and its allies sought to ramp up pressure on Kim Jong Un to abandon his nuclear ambitions.Speaking at the Un…
  4. Trump set to roll back some limits on drone strikes and raids: report - Politics
    09.22 / 03:11
    The Trump administration is set to roll back various limits on drone strikes and commando raids put in place under former President Barack Obama, The New York Times reported Thursday.Under the policy, strikes would be expanded to include …
  5. Feelin’ Lucky? — Registering for the DV-Lottery in 2017 - Politics
    09.22 / 03:10
    By R. Mark Frey The Diversity Immigrant Visa Program, also known as the DV-Lottery Program, came into existence following passage of the Immigration Act of 1990. It’s unique by the fa…
  6. Nevada GOP gov rips ObamaCare repeal bill: Flexibility it promises 'a false choice' - Politics
    09.22 / 03:02
    "I will not pit seniors, children, families, the mentally ill, the critically ill, hospitals, care providers, or any other Nevadan against each," GOP governor…
  7. Tillerson urging Trump to certify Iran's compliance with nuclear deal: report - Politics
    09.22 / 03:02
    Secretary of State Rex Tillerson is urging President Trump to certify to Congress that Iran is complying with the Iran nuclear accord, following reports that Trump may make major amendments to the deal, …
  8. Alabama GOP Senate Candidates Fight Over Who Loves Trump More During Insane Debate - Politics
    09.22 / 02:55
    The two men jockeying to be the U.S. Senator from Alabama were wrapping their arms around the most dangerously incompetent and unfit commanders-in-chief the United States has ever…
  9. Zuckerberg Announces Facebook's Plans To Combat Election Interference - Politics
    09.22 / 02:53
    Watch Video"I don't want anyone to use our tools to undermine democracy. That's not what we stand for," Mark Zuckerberg announced Thursday. After Facebook revealed Russia-linked political ads were spread improperly on its site, Zuckerberg laid out the company's nine-step plan to combat election interference — not just in the U.S., but around the world. The first two steps involved the ongoing investigations by both Facebook and the U.S. government into what happened d…
  10. US beefs up NKorea sanctions, Kim Jong Un insults Trump, - Politics
    09.22 / 02:51
    President Donald Trump added economic action to his fiery military threats against North Korea on Thursday, authorizing stiffer new sanctions in response to the Koreans' nuclear weapons advances. Its leader … Click to Continue…
  11. Palin: Vote for Roy Moore Isn’t Vote Against Trump; It’s a Vote for MAGA Agenda - Politics
    09.22 / 02:45
    Former Alaska Governor Sarah Palin said a vote for Alabama grassroots Senate candidate Judge Roy Moore is a vote for the economic nationalist agenda that got President Donald Trump elected and not a vote against Trump…
  12. Low Energy: Luther Strange Reminds Audience ‘The President Picked Me’ Some 28 Times - Politics
    09.22 / 02:45
    Luther Strange spent much of his time during a debate with Judge Roy Moore Thursday evening touting what he called his “close, personal friendship” with President Donald Trump, who has endorsed his candidacy for the U.S. Sen…
  13. Alabama Senate Candidate Roy Moore: ‘I Believe in a Strong Military’ - Politics
    09.22 / 02:45
    Alabama Republican Senate candidate Roy Moore said Thursday during a debate against rival Luther Strange that he backed President Trump's decision to end transgender individuals serving in the…
  14. Louie Gohmert at Judge Roy Moore Rally: Trump Got Bad Advice - Politics
    09.22 / 02:45
    At a post-debate rally in Montgomery, Alabama, Thursday evening, Rep. Louie Gohmert (R-TX) delivered a resounding endorsement of former Alabama Chief Justice Roy Moore for U.S. Senate. Gohmert strongly implied President Donald Trump endorsed opponent Sen. Luther Strange based on "bad…
  15. Is ‘White Supremacy’ a Scapegoat for Waning Democratic Appeal? - Politics
    While Ta-Nehisi Coates claims racists elected Trump, the actual voters suggest…
  16. OP-ED | Put Smartphones on Pause - Politics
    09.22 / 02:44
    As a teacher of nearly 20 years, I gave up the notion of being able to control educational policy writ large a long time ago. Often telling my students, “If I were king of the world, things would be different,” I have been content to control what happened in the sanctuary of my classroom. However, recent societal trends snapped me out of my apathy and, rather than challenge policy makers, I want to appeal to parents. So, to the moms and dads out there — please — do…
  17. Man accused of disrupting flight found competent for trial
    09.22 / 02:34
  18. Megyn Kelly hopes for a Trump-free zone with new show
    09.22 / 02:34
  19. Congressman: McCain 'staring death in face' before healthcare vote

    09.22 / 02:34
    Rep. Matt Cartwright, D-Penn., suggested that Sen. John McCain's brain cancer will help him resist GOP pressure to vote for the Graham-Cassidy…
  20. Ex-CIA operative apologizes for tweet of anti-Semitic article

    CNN - Politics
    09.22 / 02:33
    Former CIA operative Valerie Plame Wilson is apologizing after tweeting an anti-Semitic article titled "America's Jews Are Driving America's Wars" on…