Govt uses ‘adverse’ IB reports to reject names of 6 former judges for tribunals, commissions


Govt uses ‘adverse’ IB reports to reject names of 6 former judges for tribunals, commissions
  1. Govt uses ‘adverse’ IB reports to reject names of 6 former judges for tribunals, commissions
    indianexpress.com
    The Supreme Court. (File Photo) ARGUING over the Memorandum of Procedure, the Supreme Court has refused to agree to a Government veto on a judge’s appointment on grounds of national security. But as the faceoff continues, the Centre has used “secret” inputs provided by the Intelligence Bureau (IB) to block post-retirement assignments to former judges. The Indian Express has learnt that over the last few …
    Top Stories
supreme court, supreme court jurisdiction, judicial diktats, enforcement of decrees, npas, non performing assets, Article 142, indian constitution, india news, latest news The Supreme Court. (File Photo)

ARGUING over the Memorandum of Procedure, the Supreme Court has refused to agree to a Government veto on a judge’s appointment on grounds of national security. But as the faceoff continues, the Centre has used “secret” inputs provided by the Intelligence Bureau (IB) to block post-retirement assignments to former judges. The Indian Express has learnt that over the last few months, citing “adverse IB reports,” the Centre has rejected the candidature of six former judges for posting as chairpersons or members of tribunals and commissions.

The six include: two judges who recently retired from the Supreme Court; two who retired as Chief Justices of High Courts; and two former HC judges.

These judges, it is learnt, were recommended by the judiciary for appointments to panels that include Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal, Competition Appellate Tribunal, National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, National Company Law Tribunal and Armed Forces Tribunal.

The judges’ names were sent for approval to the Appointments Committee of the Cabinet (ACC) after due diligence by the administrative ministry concerned.

While four former judges were not cleared for the job by the ACC on grounds of “adverse IB reports,” two other names were sent back by the ACC without ascribing any reason.

In the case of two of the nominees — both retired High Court judges — the fact that there was an “adverse” IB report about them has been recorded on file by the Cabinet Secretariat, thereby ensuring that they aren’t likely to be considered for any post-retirement jobs in the government again.

In post-retirement appointments, the government is not rule-bound to accept the judiciary’s recommendation but has to provide sufficient grounds for turning it down.

Interestingly, in the case of one former Supreme Court judge, the government disregarded an “adverse IB input” and appointed him as member of a tribunal.

Sources said this rejection on the basis of IB reports, which contain little or virtually no c…

  1. Wanda inks deal with Abbott World Marathon Majors

    China.org.cn - Top news
    04.26 / 11:45 www.china.org.cn
    China's Wanda Group put pen to paper on a partnership deal with the Abbott World Marathon Majors (WMM) here on Wednesday, in an agreement that will see three major marathon events held in Asia within the next 10…
  2. Usurers overrun Chinese university campuses

    China.org.cn - Top news
    04.26 / 07:08 www.china.org.cn
    The financial safety of Chinese university students is being challenged by usurers overrunning campuses in search of quick…
  3. 6-year-old girl's Silk Road adventure book released

    China.org.cn - Top news
    04.26 / 06:52 www.china.org.cn
    The English version of “Biking the Silk Road: 6-year-old Sophia’s Fantasy Tour,” published by New World Press, was released in Beijing on Tuesd…
  4. Korea crisis: Threats do not promote human rights

    China.org.cn - Top news
    04.26 / 02:52 www.china.org.cn
    The peace, human rights, and expanding economic development are not being advanced by the threats of war or economic isolation of the…
  5. China's first home-built aircraft carrier hits the water

    China.org.cn - Top news
    04.26 / 02:15 www.china.org.cn
    China launched its second aircraft carrier Wednesday morning in northeast China's Dalian shipyard in Liaoning…
  6. Ministry to oversee cleanup of dump sites in Hebei, Tianjin

    China.org.cn - Top news
    04.26 / 01:26 www.china.org.cn
    The Ministry of Environmental Protection said that it will supervise the treatment and restoration of polluted dump sites in Hebei Province and…
  7. Central China ideal destination for foreign investment

    China.org.cn - Top news
    04.26 / 01:10 www.china.org.cn
    Central China is becoming an ideal destination for foreign investment, according to a senior commerce official…
  8. 25 CRPF personnel killed in Sukma: Day after, ground Zero; ‘intel failure, human shields and huge arms loot’

    Indianexpress.com - Top news
    04.25 / 23:46 indianexpress.com
    On Tuesday, these are the signs that tell the tale at Ground Zero, of the worst Maoist attack in Chhattisgarh in seven years. THE ROAD is orange, indicating that work on it is incomplete. Two small bridges stand forlorn and half-made, dusty diversions circumventing them. Deep inside Sukma, this is what the CRPF sought to protect when they were ambushed by Maoists Monday, leading to the death of 25…
  9. PDP old guard looks beyond Mehbooba Mufti, she digs her heels in

    Indianexpress.com - Top news
    04.25 / 23:38 indianexpress.com
    J&K Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti (File Photo) Rebuffed by the Centre on starting a dialogue with stakeholders in the Valley, J&K Chief Minister Mehbooba Mufti has returned to Srinagar where she is not only grappling with a crisis that threatens the future of the ruling PDP-BJP alliance but is also staring at a rebellion in her own party. While the BJP continues to play “tough”, sources said at least thr…
  10. In an early warning, Naxals killed Sarpanch 2 months ago

    Indianexpress.com - Top news
    04.25 / 23:38 indianexpress.com
    “It is clear that we had very little information. This is something that will have to be worked on,” said an officer.(Source: Google maps) WITH INTELLIGENCE failure being blamed for Monday’s attack on CRPF jawans in Sukma’s Burkapal, senior officers said that the murder of the village headman two months ago by Maoists led to an “information deficit”. CRPF officers admitted that they had little or no inte…
  11. Sukma attack: CRPF asked for new tech for faster roads but…

    Indianexpress.com - Top news
    04.25 / 23:24 indianexpress.com
    The road in Sukma that the CRPF was guarding. Source: Dipankar Ghose CRPF OFFICERS admit that Maoists were able to target a battalion in Sukma Monday, leading to 25 deaths, because of the predictability of the route taken by the personnel to reach their destination — a road-construction site. With a kilometre of construction in such terrain taking 15-20 days, they say faster road work is the only s…
  12. EC bribery case: Delhi police arrest T T V Dinakaran

    Indianexpress.com - Top news
    04.25 / 23:20 indianexpress.com
    Police sources said Dinakaran and Mallikarjuna were arrested after being questioned at length Tuesday. (File photo) Five days after he was made to step down as deputy general secretary of the AIADMK, T T V Dinakaran, nephew of the jailed party general secretary V K Sasikala, and his friend Mallikarjuna were arrested Tuesday night by Delhi Police for allegedly trying to bribe an Election Commission…
  13. Bombay HC ruling in Malegaon 2008 blast: Bail for Sadhvi after NIA clean chit but no relief for Prasad Purohit

    Indianexpress.com - Top news
    04.25 / 23:11 indianexpress.com
    Col. Prasad Shrikant Purohit (left), Sadhavi Pragya The Bombay High Court granted bail Tuesday to Sadhvi Pragya Singh Thakur, a key accused in the 2008 bomb blast in Malegaon in which six persons were killed and over 100 injured. The High Court, however, rejected the bail of another accused in the case, former Lt Colonel Prasad Purohit, saying the accusations against Purohit seem “prima facie true”. Pur…
  14. Placed on FCRA blacklist, PHFI worked with govts, from Chhattisgarh to North East

    Indianexpress.com - Top news
    04.25 / 23:01 indianexpress.com
    In 2015, the BJP government of Chhattisgarh, represented by health minister Ajay Chandrakar, signed an MoU with PHFI to upgrade specialist doctors in Naxal-hit Bastar. SINCE last week, the top public health NGO Public Health Foundation of India (PHFI) has been in the crosshairs of the NDA government, barred from accepting foreign funds. But not very long ago, it was the preferred partner of not just the…
  15. Eyes on Bengal prize, BJP plans Syama Prasad Mookerjee museum and archives in Kolkata

    Indianexpress.com - Top news
    04.25 / 22:52 indianexpress.com
    Syama Prasad Mookerjee’s house in Kolkata. Source: Subham Dutta As the BJP turns its gaze towards West Bengal, its government at the Centre plans to open a museum in Kolkata with a permanent exhibition on Syama Prasad Mookerjee, founder of the Bharatiya Jana Sangh which became the BJP a quarter century later. Moves are afoot to compile and publish the works of Mookerjee within a year, and spread a…