What Happened When Dylann Roof Asked Google For Information About Race?

What Happened When Dylann Roof Asked Google For Information About Race?
  1. What Happened When Dylann Roof Asked Google For Information About Race?
    Dylann Roof murdered nine people in a church basement in Charleston in 2015. He confessed to the massacre shortly after he was arrested. He didn't testify at trial and no witnesses were called on his behalf before he was convicted of federal hate crimes. The most emphatic statements on Roof's behalf came from defense attorney David Bruck. For weeks, the prosecution had presented evidence that Roof is a white supremacist whose violent racism drove him to kill black people. Bruck asked the…
    Delaware (DE)

Dylann Roof murdered nine people in a church basement in Charleston in 2015.

He confessed to the massacre shortly after he was arrested. He didn't testify at trial and no witnesses were called on his behalf before he was convicted of federal hate crimes.

The most emphatic statements on Roof's behalf came from defense attorney David Bruck. For weeks, the prosecution had presented evidence that Roof is a white supremacist whose violent racism drove him to kill black people. Bruck asked the jury to consider how the 22-year-old came to believe the things he did.

As NPR reported:

" 'There is hatred all right, and certainly racism, but it goes a lot further than that,' [Bruck] said.

" 'Every bit of motivation came from things he saw on the internet. That's it. ... 'He is simply regurgitating, in whole paragraphs, slogans and facts — bits and pieces of facts that he downloaded from the internet directly into his brain.' "

Bruck was referring to Roof's assertion in his confession and in a manifesto that a Google search shaped his beliefs.

So when Roof asked Google for information about race, what did the search engine show him?

The Internet And Trayvon Martin

"The event that truly awakened me was the Trayvon Martin case," Roof wrote in the racist manifesto he published online, a cached version of which was saved to Internet archive sites.

Roof was 17 years old at the time, the same age Trayvon Martin was when neighborhood watch volunteer George Zimmerman shot and killed the unarmed black teenager in 2012.

"I kept hearing and seeing [Martin's] name," Roof wrote, "and eventually I decided to look him up." Roof wrote that he "read the Wikipedia article" about the shooting and came to the conclusion that Zimmerman was not at fault.

"But," he continued, "more importantly this prompted me to type in the words 'black on White crime' into Google, and I have never been the same since that day."

In a videotaped interview with FBI agents after he was arrested in June 2015, Roof told a similar story. He said that after hearing about Martin's death he had "decided to look his name up. Type him into Google, you know what I'm saying?"

Roof told investigators he had read the Wikipedia article for Martin, and then, "for some reason after I read that, I," he paused before continuing, "I typed in — for some reason it made me type in the words black on white crime."

"And that was it," Roof said. "Ever since then ..." he trailed off and didn't finish the sentence.

It is impossible to know what Roof saw when he typed those words into Google. The search engine does not make the details of its search algorithm public, and even if the exact date and location of Roof's initial search was known (court documents suggest only that it was around 2013), there is no public archive of past search results.

"Even the Wayback Machine, which is maintained by the Internet Archive, does not preserve search rankings," explains Robert Epstein, a psychologist who studies how people interact with search engines and who has published multiple studies about Google's algorithm.

"You can find old versions of Web pages," he says, but "all this past stuff — search suggestions, search results — you cannot get to."

Epstein says the closest approximation of what Roof saw on Google begins with the search engine's "autocomplete" feature.

Taking Roof's statements at face value, he went to Google.com and typed the letters in his search term, one at a time.

But he didn't necessarily have to type all the letters in the search term, "b-l-a-c-k o-n w-h-i-t-e c-r-i-m-e." NPR googled that phrase in December 2016 and January 2017, and found the letters "b-l-a-c-k o-n" elicited this top autocompleted suggestion: "black on white crime."

Users need only press enter to complete the search.

Adding one letter to make it "b-l-a-c-k o-n w", the top autocomplete suggestion remained the same, and the second was "black on white violence." The third and fourth were "black on white crime statistics" and "black on white racism."

The top autocomplete results for "w-h-i-t-e o-n w" were "white on white crime," "white on white," "white on white acid" and "white on white kitchen."

A spokesperson for Google told NPR in an email that "autocomplete predictions are produced based on a number of factors including the popularity and freshness of search terms."

"We do our best to prevent offensive terms, like porn and hate speech, from appearing, but we don't always get it right," the spokesperson continued and pointed to a June 2016 blog post by the search engine's product management director, Tamar Yehoshua, saying Google had changed its algorithm to "avoid completing a search for a person's name with terms that are offensive or disparaging."

Search Results As 'Propaganda' Tools

When Roof hit Enter for the search term "black on white crime," the search engine returned a list of websites. "The first website I came to was the Council of Conservative Citizens," Roof wrote.

The Council of Conservative Citizens is a white supremacist organization, according to the Anti-Defamation League, which tracks hate groups. In the aftermath of the Trayvon Martin shooting, the ADL reported that multiple hate groups used inaccurate Internet posts about crimes against white people as a "propaganda tool" for white supremacy.

As the ADL reported:

"On May 11, 2012, the white supremacist Council of Conservative Citizens (CofCC) posted an article on its Web site that claimed that a New Jersey newspaper had 'censored' the race of the alleged assailants in what it called 'savage mob attacks' on five white concertgoers in New Jersey. The CofCC dismissed both the newspaper and police accounts portraying the incident as an 'isolated event.' According to the CofCC, 'almost as alarming as the epidemic violent crime being perpetrated against white people is the blatant media censorship and black-out of the racial element of the incidents.'"

It's impossible to know whether the Council of Conservative Citizens page that Roof referenced appeared at the top of the Google search results. Results for a given search term and the order in which they're presented change over time.

Google searches for "black on white crime" conducted by NPR in December 2016 and January 2017 found the top results included multiple white supremacist websites, but didn't include anything from the Council of Conservative Citizens.

The top five results included the website New Nation News, which the Anti-Defamation League says "promotes the belief that 'voluntary racial segregation in all prisons is a constitutional right,' " and American Renaissance, a magazine put out by what the Southern Poverty Law Center calls "a self-styled think tank that promotes pseudo-scientific studies and research that purport to show the inferiority of blacks to whites."

The first page of results also included an article published on the website The Root titled, "Open Letter to White People Who Are Obsessed With Black-on-Black Crime," and a link to a forum about "Black on White Crime" on the neo-Nazi site The Daily Stormer.

"The two positions in the search results matter the most," says Epstein, who has studied click rates for search results. "Th…

  1. Will 2017 Be Realty Income Corporation's Best Year Yet?

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 19:42 wgmd.com
    Retail REIT Realty Income (NYSE: O) gave investors several reasons to smile in 2016. Just to name a few, the stock’s dividend grew by about 6% throughout the year, the company acquired twice as many properties as it expected, and at record-low costs of capital. Realty Income’s 8.6% total return in 2016 was fairly strong.…
  2. Joe Biden takes Amtrak home after inauguration

    Delawareonline.com - Wilmington -
    01.20 / 19:28 delawareonline.com
    A jovial, recently dethroned Vice President Joe Biden arrived at an eerily quiet train platform Friday to take his beloved Amtrak from Washington’s Union Station back home to W…
  3. Carmelo Anthony says if Knicks want him out, he'd 'have to consider it'

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 18:28 wgmd.com
    Carmelo Anthony forced his way out of Denver during the 2011 season because he wanted to live and play in New York City. Even during the roughest of seasons with the Knicks, he’s never once mentioned the possibility of waiving his no-trade clause to play somewhere else — until now. New York is in the…
  4. Guy Martin to return to Isle of Man TT

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 18:28 wgmd.com
    After a year away from the event, 35-year-old Guy Martin will return to competition this June at the 2017 Isle of Man TT. Considered one of the best current road racers without a TT win, Martin will partner 23-time TT winner John McGuinness at Honda Racing on the all-new Honda CBR1000RR Fireblade SP2 superbike. The…
  5. Defiant Orlando cop-killing suspect interrupts judge in court

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 17:15 wgmd.com
    A day after an expletive-laced court appearance on charges he killed his pregnant ex-girlfriend, a fugitive was more subdued but still interrupted and refused to answer questions when he went before a judge Friday on five new charges filed against him in the death of Orlando police officer. ACCUSED COP-KILLER CURSES OUT JUDGE, SAYS HE’LL…
  6. All 55 cars for the Rolex 24 at Daytona

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 17:14 wgmd.com
    — Twelve new-for-2017 Prototypes will take part, alongside five Prototype Challenge, 11 GT Le Mans and 27 GT Daytona entries. — The only notable change on the driver front in the P class with Brendon Hartley listed in both ESM Nissans, after having originally been announced for the No. 22 entry only. — The PC class, now in its final…
  7. Delawareans endure cold, long lines for Trump inaugural

    Delawareonline.com - Wilmington -
    01.20 / 17:01 delawareonline.com
    Despite the hassles of the mammoth event, the visitors are excited to witness…
  8. Drug lord 'El Chapo' Guzman arrives in New York to face charges

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 16:37 wgmd.com
    NEW YORK –  Infamous Mexican drug kingpin Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman, who twice escaped from maximum-security prisons in his country, was extradited at the request of the United States to face drug trafficking and other charges and arrived in New York late Thursday. TIMING OF EXTRADITION SEEN AS POLITICAL A plane carrying Guzman landed at…
  9. Trump aides meeting with Mexican foreign, economy ministers next week

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 15:24 wgmd.com
    President-Elect Donald Trump’s top aides and senior Mexican officials, including President Enrique Peña Nieto’s closest aide and confidant, will meet next week in Washington D.C., the Mexican government said in a statement. Mexico’s Foreign Minister Luis Videgaray and Economy Minister Ildefonso Guajardo will head talks next Wednesday and Thursday with Trump’s chief-of-staff Reince Priebus and…
  10. Live: Scenes from Trump-Pence Inauguration Day

    Thestarpress.com - Delaware
    01.20 / 14:01 thestarpress.com
    IndyStar will keep you posted on everything going on with Donald Trump's inauguration — and Vice President-elect Mike Pence's new role in Washington, too — in this live blog.…
  11. Governor Carney Accepts Policy Report from Transition Committee

    News.delaware.gov - Delaware (DE)
    01.20 / 13:35 news.delaware.gov
    Governor John Carney received a final report from the Transition Committee that includes recommended action steps in order to achieve policy objectives set forth by the…
  12. Inauguration Day weather forecast: gray and wet

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 12:57 wgmd.com
    The thousands of people heading to Washington to see Donald Trump take his oath as the country’s 45th president might consider taking a rain jacket or poncho. Meteorologists are forecasting that Washington, D.C. will be gray and damp on Inauguration Day. Rain is moving and is expected to reach the capital shortly before noon –…
  13. ISIS Destroys Ancient Theater, Tetrapylon In Palmyra, Syria Says

    Delawarepublic.org - Dover
    01.20 / 12:43 delawarepublic.org
    Two famous ancient structures in the city of Palmyra have been destroyed by ISIS forces, Syria's antiquities chief says. The Tetrapylon and the facade of the city's Roman theater have both been almost completely demolished, the official says, according to NPR's Alison Meuse. "Activist Khaled al-Homsi, who is from Palmyra, shared satellite imagery to Twitter, which appears to confirm the scale of the damage," Alison reports. "The face of the Roman theater is a pile of rubble and only four…
  14. Were Egyptian 'pot burials' a symbol of rebirth?

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 12:22 wgmd.com
    Ancient Egyptians who buried their deceased kin in pots may have chosen the burial vessels as symbols of the womb and rebirth, scientists argue in a new paper. Pot burials in ancient Egypt have long been considered the domain of the very poor. In a paper published in the journal Antiquity, however, archaeologists Ronika Power…
  15. Mud cracks on Mars suggest a watery ancient past

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 12:22 wgmd.com
    NASA’s Curiosity rover has photographed shallow crevices on Mars that may have formed from ancient mud cracks, yet more evidence that the planet had a watery past. The photos, taken Dec. 20 and unveiled Tuesday (Jan. 17), show a site called “Old Soaker” on Mars’ lower Mount Sharp. Scientists think the cracked layer likely formed…
  16. Miami Marlins Turn Ballpark into a Racetrack

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 12:21 wgmd.com
    Every team looks for a way to utilize their ballpark during the MLB offseason. The Miami Marlins have done just that in a truly novel way, as they turned Marlins Park into a racetrack. Fans of the Miami Marlins are certainly used to seeing speed at the ol’ home field. Dee Gordon stole 30 bases…
  17. The Cleveland Cavaliers Need More from Iman Shumpert… Or Else

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 12:20 wgmd.com
    While J.R. Smith has been absent, the Cleveland Cavaliers haven’t had the production that they expected from Iman Shumpert and that has to change. Iman Shumpert was acquired in a trade that sent both him and J.R. Smith to the Cleveland Cavaliers from the New York Knicks during the 2014-2015 season. While this was a…
  18. Two Frankford Men Arrested In Robberies

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 10:29 wgmd.com
    Two Frankford men were arrested Wednesday in connection with multiple robberies in the area. 19-year-old Matthew Edwards and 20-year-old Zack Umstead were arrested after breaking into a Royal Farms and a Dash Inn on John J Williams Highway. The first robbery happened at the Royal Farms just before 4 a.m., when one went into the…
  19. No. 3 Bruins too strong for Sun Devils

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 09:18 wgmd.com
    LOS ANGELES — Like any shooter in a slump, Isaac Hamilton just kept putting the ball up, figuring it would eventually go in. Did it ever. The senior guard scored 33 points — three off his career best — and hit a career-high nine 3-pointers to help No. 3 UCLA rout Arizona State 102-80 on…
  20. Sacramento Kings: Game 42 Preview at Memphis Grizzlies

    Wgmd.com -  Delmarva
    01.20 / 09:17 wgmd.com
    The Sacramento Kings travel to take on the Memphis Grizzlies on January 20, 2017.  This article provides a preview of that game from a Kings’ perspective. The Sacramento Kings start an eight-game road trip against the Memphis Grizzlies tonight.  This is the third of four meetings between the teams this season.  The Kings traveled to…