How to reconcile Colombia?


How to reconcile Colombia?
  1. How to reconcile Colombia?
    colombiareports.com
    2017 could mark the dawn of a new era for Colombia following the signing of peace with Marxist FARC rebels. After more than half a century of conflict, the country enters a process… Read more How to reconcile Co…
    Latin America

2017 could mark the dawn of a new era for Colombia following the signing of peace with Marxist FARC rebels. After more than half a century of conflict, the country enters a process that ultimately seeks reconciliation.

Colombia will now begin the arduous task of attempting to heal the wounds from 52 years of brutal war that caused the deaths of at least 260,000 people at the hands of both the government and the FARC, but how?

While conceding that there is no “one size fits all” model for post-conflict reconciliation, the United Nations’ International Institute for Democracy and Electoral Assistance (IDEA) compiled a publication analyzing post-conflict reconciliation efforts worldwide, some of which may be applicable to the Colombian context.

With the demobilization process already in progress and the inception of a Truth Commission and Transitional Justice Tribunal imminent, Colombia will soon encounter some of the issues raised in the UN’s “Reconciliation After Violent Conflict: A Handbook.”

Due to the extreme delicate nature of any post-conflict reconciliation process, the steps that Colombia takes in the coming weeks, months and years will shape the very society that the country’s future generations will grow up in.

Reconciliation is not a luxury, or an add-on to democracy. Reconciliation is an absolute necessity.  At its simplest, it means finding a way to live alongside former enemies – not necessarily to love them, or forgive them, or forget the past in any way, but to coexist with them, to develop the degree of cooperation necessary to share our society with them, so that we all have better lives together than we have had separately.

IDEA
Colombia’s 2012 – 2016 peace talks | Fact sheet

The observations of the handbook highlight certain aspects of reconciliation processes that have been common to many countries and yielded success as well as potential pitfalls for which Colombia must prepare itself.

1 – Timing and trust building

For a reconciliation process to make a solid beginning and foster trust between all concerned, the timing of it initiation will be crucial.

52 years of conflict, more than 8 million victims, tens of thousands of war crimes and an immeasurable amount of mistrust between the two sides has resulted in a Colombian society that is still incredibly raw and resentful.

This was perhaps reflected by the rejection of the first peace agreement between the government and the FARC in an October 2 referendum. In that referendum, Colombian voters rejected compromises made with the guerrillas.

Such rawness, and in many cases outright opposition to the agreement across Colombia’s society makes the timing of the initiation of reconciliation processes crucial in terms of trust-building for all sides involved.

According to the IDEA handbook, “a rushed approach to reconciliation will almost certainly be counterproductive,” which adds that “in the immediate aftermath of a civil war or of an inhuman regime, victims are too preoccupied with their own distress to develop trust and empathy in a hurry.”

For this reason, Colombia may be best served by initially focusing on the establishment of the “Transitional Justice Tribunal” and a “Truth Commission” as a first step towards building trust with the victims of the conflict and gradually working towards the beginning of the truth-telling and reconciliation process.

Colombia’s transitional justice system ‘needs 6 months to take effect’

The transitional justice system will review amnesty requests of the FARC’s approximately 6,600 guerrilla fighters and 10,000 militia members, process 24,400 state officials either sentenced or indicted for war crimes and an additional 12,500 private persons and enterprises accused of financially supporting one of the illegal armed groups active in the conflict.

This transitional justice system is likely to take effect in immediate aftermath of FARC demobilization and will get the ball rolling on hearing accounts of the crimes committed during the conflict.

While the IDEA handbook advocates starting the process of of reconciliation early enough to benefit from the momentum of the peace agreement, it urges those involved to think long term as the “reconciliation must be seen as a long-term process that may take decades or generations.”

2 – Telling the truth

Following the demobilization process, the setting up of the Transitional Justice Tribunal and Truth Commission will play a key role in the reconciliation process, allowing victims and perpetrators to come to terms with their past differences and build towards a more unified future.

IDEA reported that at least 25 official truth commissions have been established around the world since 1974, providing a public platform for victims, promoting public debate and bringing about reparation and reconciliation.

In a positive way these commissions “can put victims – long ignored and forgotten by the public – at the forefront and center of the transition process. This can help to make victims whole again, both individually and as a group, and give them a sense of personal vindication,” read the document.

Everything that’s good about Colombia’s transitional justice system

Despite the many benefits that have been documented from truth commissions around the world, the UN document urges caution in certain respects.

Governments ranging from Spain in the 1970’s, Cambodia in the 1980’s to Mozambique in the 1990’s opted to not put a truth commission in place for fear that the peace process in general may not benefit from it.

While it may be necessary to air the truth of events in the past, it is also important that the truth commission is not abused for political gain or that it does not lead to prolonged dwelling on flash-points that may corrode the resolution process, IDEA warned.

With the Truth Commission due to take effect this year in Colombia, realistic expectations must be fostered as the process may affect victims and particular groups in a different way depending on the context and severity of the situation.

“Forgiveness, healing and reconciliation are deeply personal processes, and each person’s needs and reactions to peacemaking and truth-telling may be different.”

IDEA

3 – A balance between impunity and justice

While the UN view truth telling as imperative for the progression of reconciliation,  the administration of adequate justice to offenders during the conflict is also strongly advocated.

In particular they specify the importance of a balance between justice that respects the suffering of the victims and impunity that allows for the transition of all sides from war to peace and reconciliation to take place.

If the victims in a society do not feel that their suffering has been acknowledged, then they . . . are not ready to put the past behind them. If they know that the horrible crimes carried out in secret will always remain buried . . . then they are not ready for reconciliation”.

IDEA

Up to now many Colombians have expressed strong concerns regarding the justice that will be administered to the perpetrators of war crimes during the conflict with the agreement specifying that offenders from the FARC and the military who fully cooperate with justice will not spend one single day in prison.

Instead, convicted war criminals may be sentenced to a “restriction of liberties” which would see those who have committed grievous crimes of kidnapping, murder and rape effectively doing community service.

War criminals who refuse to cooperate or only partially cooperate will most definitely be sent to prison and could serve as many as 20 years behind bars.

A 15-year history of peace with impunity in Colombia

Colombia must strive to achieve this balance between impunity and justice in order to make reconciliation possible with an avoidance of amnesia regarding the crimes a priority.

This lesson can be taken from the experience of Zimbabwe where the army committed gross human rights violations in Matabeleland between 1983 and 1985. This remained unacknowledged until 1997, when two NGOs published a report titled “Breaking the Silence.”

The covering up of truth and failure to administer justice led to the failure of reconciliation in the Zimbabwean context with politicians arguing that silence about the past was “what the newborn country needed.”

The white heirs of the Rhodesian regime and the black leaders preferred to impose a shallow, “cheap” form of reconciliation without historical, restorative or economic justice. Cheap, imposed and based (for whatever pragmatic reasons) on amnesia and impunity – in such a form, reconciliation can only damage fundamentally the prospect of a viable, peaceful and inclusive Zimbabwean democracy.

IDEA

The manner in which all involved in Colombia approach this will be crucial in terms of achieving reconciliation.

The UN handbook issues a strong warning that “the kind of reconciliation that lets bygones be bygones is not true reconciliation. It is reconciliation at gunpoint and authorities should not and cannot impose trust and empathy by decree.”

Nonetheless it does acknowledge that “to strike a balance between the demands of repressive justice and of reconciliation is no easy enterprise. It entails a difficult and, on occasion, tortuous cost–benefit analysis. All costs and gains must be balanced against each other.”

With this example in mind, the success of long-term, effective reconciliation may depend on how the Transitional Justice Tribunal deals with the war criminals that are presented before it.

4 – All inclusive reconciliation dialogue

While the many elements of post-conflict resolution may take time to put in place, the ultimate aim must be for reconciliation dialogue involving all sides to take place.

The crucial phase of the reconciliation process will begin when Colombians are ready to talk, both victims and perpetrators.

The sheer delicacy and sensitivity of this stage will be present major challenges particularly regarding the finding the language to facilitate dialogue which was duly noted by the IDEA.

In Rwanda, for example, the attitude of the government in the years that followed the genocide was to insist on the need for justice. The word ‘reconciliation’ was taboo for those who had survived genocide, and was never publicly used…. In…

  1. Brote de fiebre amarilla tiene en emergencia sanitaria a Brasil

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.18 / 03:58 latincorrespondent.com
    En el Estado de Minas Gerais, en el sudeste de Brasil, se registra un brote de fiebre amarilla que mantiene en emergencia sanitaria al país. En lo que va corrido del año ya serían 50 los muertos y cientos los potenciales casos que se encuentran en investigación. El ministerio de Salud Pública (MSP) recomendó a... Read more » The post Brote de fiebre amarilla tiene en emergencia sanitaria a Brasil appeared first on Latin Corre…
  2. Las fuertes lluvias provocarían el cierre de un pueblo argentino

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.18 / 03:18 latincorrespondent.com
    Las constantes lluvias que azotan a la provincia de Santa Fe, ubicada en el centro-este de la Argentina, provocarían el cierre inminente de una población entera. Las autoridades de la localidad de Marini se fijaron un plazo de dos meses para concretar esta determinación si la situación no mejora. El jefe comunal, Gerardo Piombo, tomó la... Read more » The post Las fuertes lluvias provocarían el cierre de un pueblo argentino appeared first on Latin Corres…
  3. Seis excursionistas perdieron la vida en el volcán Acatenango de Guatemala

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.18 / 02:57 latincorrespondent.com
    Un grupo de montañistas decidió escalar el volcán inactivo Acatenango, en cercanías de la ciudad de Antigua, Guatemala, en medio de un frente frío que alcanzó a bajar a 15 grados bajo cero. Seis de ellos murieron y seis fueron rescatados, entre los cuales hay dos heridos tras sufrir de hipotermia. Al Hospital Nacional de esa localidad... Read more » The post Seis excursionistas perdieron la vida en el volcán Acatenango de Guatemala appeared first on Latin Correspo…
  4. Colombia awaits “big changes” with arrival of Trump: Defense Minister

    Colombiareports.com - Colombia
    01.17 / 22:02 colombiareports.com
    Colombia’s Defense Minister is expecting “big changes” economically and “drastic change in the rules of the game” with the incoming Trump administration in the United States, but not right away, he… Read more Colombia awaits “big changes” with arrival of Trump: Defense …
  5. Después de la masacre de 26 presos, cárcel de Natal sigue en crisis

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.17 / 19:11 latincorrespondent.com
    La policía brasileña usó balas de goma y gas lacrimógeno para romper un nuevo enfrentamiento entre bandas de narcotraficantes en una cárcel donde 26 presos fueron asesinados en los últimos días. El comandante Eduardo Franco, portavoz de la policía en el estado de Rio Grande do Norte, donde se encuentra la prisión de Alcaçuz, dijo... Read more » The post Después de la masacre de 26 presos, cárcel de Natal sigue en crisis appeared first on Latin Corresponde…
  6. Colombia’s economic growth for 2017 projected at 2.5%: World Bank

    Colombiareports.com - Colombia
    01.16 / 20:45 colombiareports.com
    The World Bank projected economic growth at 2.5% for Colombia in 2017 in its semi-annual Global Economic Prospects report released last week. The projection is over double the 1.2% growth… Read more Colombia’s economic growth for 2017 projected at 2.5%: World…
  7. Triángulo norte centroamericano es la región sin guerra más mortífera del mundo, según ACNUR

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.16 / 18:28 latincorrespondent.com
    Cuando Juan caminaba a la escuela una mañana hace un año en El Salvador, dos hombres en una moto pasaron a toda velocidad y le dispararon de muerte a otro muchacho en la calle frente a él. El tirador echó una buena mirada a la cara de Juan. Como testigo de un asesinato de pandillas,... Read more » The post Triángulo norte centroamericano es la región sin guerra más mortífera del mundo, según ACNUR appeared first on Latin Correspo…
  8. El ‘Gasolinazo’: la medida que movilizó a México contra las alzas

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.15 / 21:01 latincorrespondent.com
    El aumento en el precio de la gasolina que rige desde el pasado primero de enero generó gran descontento en México. Miles de personas salieron a las calles para manifestarse contra el llamado “Gasolinazo” decretado por el gobierno de Enrique Peña Nieto. El costo escaló en algunos casos a más del 20 por ciento y... Read more » The post El ‘Gasolinazo’: la medida que movilizó a México contra las alzas appeared first on Latin Correspond…
  9. Detienen en Venezuela a otro opositor copartidario de Leopoldo López

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.15 / 20:59 latincorrespondent.com
    Agentes de inteligencia de Venezuela detuvieron al activista de la oposición Gilber Caro y lo acusaron de planear actos de violencia. Además, presuntamente habrían hallado armas en su poder, aunque su partido, Voluntad Popular, dijo que estas fueron colocadas en su coche por los agentes del Gobierno para incriminarlo. Caro, legislador suplente, fue detenido en... Read more » The post Detienen en Venezuela a otro opositor copartidario de Leopoldo López appeared first on Latin Cor…
  10. El último legado de Obama: no más ‘Pies secos, pies mojados’

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.15 / 20:57 latincorrespondent.com
    El gobierno del presidente Barack Obama derogó el jueves la medida que otorgaba la residencia automática a prácticamente todos los cubanos que llegaran a los Estados Unidos, con o sin visas, poniendo fin a una excepción de larga data en la política de inmigración estadounidense. La política conocida como ‘Pies secos, pies mojados’ permitió permanecer en... Read more » The post El último legado de Obama: no más ‘Pies secos, pies mojados’ appeared first on Latin …
  11. El drama de los cubanos que quedaron a medio camino hacia Estados Unidos

    Latincorrespondent.com - Latin America
    01.15 / 20:53 latincorrespondent.com
    El cubano José Enrique Manreza, que vendió su casa y sus pertenencias para embarcarse en un viaje épico por avión, autobús y a pie en busca del sueño americano, está ahora varado en una ciudad fronteriza mexicana después de que Washington terminara abruptamente con la política de inmigración conocida como ‘Pies secos, pies mojados’. El... Read more » The post El drama de los cubanos que quedaron a medio camino hacia Estados Unidos appeared first on Latin Correspon…